November 09, 2026

The Philippines is not poor in minerals; it is poor in converting them into national value. Government and industry estimates place the country’s untapped mineral wealth at more than $1 trillion, a figure supported by a 2025 analysis by John P. Causey IV for Vantage FDI. This analysis ranks the archipelago among the world’s mineral heavyweights, placing it fourth globally in copper ore with roughly 4.41 billion tons and fifth in nickel with about 5.29 million tons. Beyond these primary reserves, the Philippines holds substantial potential in cobalt, gold, silver, and early-stage rare-earth minerals. Yet, the more revealing statistic is not what lies underground; it is how little of it has been seriously studied. Only about five percent of the country’s mineral potential has been actively explored, while mining contracts cover just around three percent of the land.

That is not a failure of geology; it is a failure of governance.

The mining sector’s modest economic footprint highlights this contradiction, with mineral exports reaching approximately $7.37 billion in 2024. At year-end, the country had 58 operating mines, including 36 nickel, 11 gold, and three copper operations. Despite this endowment, mining contributes only about one percent of the gross domestic product. For a nation sitting on minerals critical for batteries, power grids, and the global energy transition, this is a surprisingly small return on a massive endowment.

This staggering gap stems from tenurial stasis, a state of paralysis where development is choked by technical incapacity and an accumulation of cancelled, withdrawn, or expired permits. The Department of Environment and Natural Resources has signaled an end to this inactivity. In October 2025, DENR Undersecretary Carlos Primo David announced new policies aimed at raising the sector’s GDP contribution to approximately two percent. Central to this pivot is the implementation of a performance-based mandate to dispose of roughly 50 idle assets through a competitive selection process.

While the instinct to mobilize national wealth is correct, as a mining tenement is a privilege granted over a public resource rather than a trophy, the phrase "Use It or Lose It" is easier to chant than to administer. Used carefully, it can pry open idle assets; used crudely, it can turn an investment reform into a litigation machine. To ensure this reform attracts serious capital, the new guidelines must be built upon a framework of five essential tasks.

The first task is classification. The government must distinguish between dormancy and strategy. Large-scale mining operates on a decadal horizon distinct from standard commercial cycles, involving a complex progression of exploration and permitting that unfolds over years. In large tenements, phased development is a strategic necessity rather than an act of neglect. A project may develop one area while studying another to ensure operational cash flow and grade control. The guidelines must separate those who cannot perform from those developing responsibly in phases to avoid punishing patient capital.

The second task is legal fidelity. Administrative guidelines cannot quietly narrow statutory rights through technicalities or retroactive disqualifications. Republic Act No. 7942 provides that mineral agreements are renewable under the same terms and conditions. The framework must ensure that filing timelines do not act as extra-statutory disqualifications that trigger forfeiture. Because regulatory stasis often results from permitting backlogs or weather disruptions, penalizing an operator for external delays could undermine the stability the policy seeks to cultivate.

The third task is ensuring title stability. Substantial capital investment is rarely allocated to assets with unresolved legal status. A tenement entangled in litigation does not constitute a bankable opportunity; rather, it represents an inherent legal risk that complicates project financing and valuation. Before any area is offered to bidders, the state should require a clean title certification to ensure the prior right was validly terminated and remains free from pending contest. Without this safeguard, competitive selection merely transfers regulatory uncertainty to the investor’s balance sheet.

The fourth task is mandating clean succession. The state should not ask new investors to become insurers of old misconduct. Environmental liabilities, unpaid royalties, and tax delinquencies should remain the legal obligation of the defaulting entity. If rehabilitation risks are assumed by a new grantee, they must be part of a transparent, valued bid package. Hidden liabilities are not governance; they are poison pills.

The fifth task is institutional transparency. Credibility depends on design; criteria for selection should be published, and financial qualifications, such as the $8.7 million minimum paid-up capital benchmark must be measurable. Furthermore, the management of bid proceeds and revolving funds must strictly adhere to Commission on Audit and Department of Budget and Management rules. This ensures the process is driven by public resource stewardship rather than bureaucratic monetization.

The country has long debated mining as a choice between unrestrained extraction and paralysis. That is a false choice. The better path is disciplined development: strict enough to weed out speculators, predictable enough to attract capital, and lawful enough to survive judicial review. A trillion-dollar endowment is merely a headline; it becomes wealth only when law, science, and environmental responsibility align. The country does not need a mining rush; it needs a mining reckoning. The treasure chest has been there all along. The question is whether the State can open it without breaking the lock.

 

Atty. Mary Louisse S. Inguillo heads the Mining Rights and Compliance Division of Global Ferronickel Holdings Inc. A finalist for Woman Lawyer of the Year at the 2025 ALB Philippine Law Awards, she manages the group’s regulatory strategies and legal adherence. She earned her Juris Doctor from the De La Salle University – Tañada-Diokno School of Law.

November 03, 2026

The Philippines is no stranger to mineral processing. It already refines domestically sourced gold and processes portions of its copper and nickel production. Yet much of its mineral wealth still leaves as raw ore or intermediate products requiring further processing abroad, allowing other economies to capture more of the value from refining, manufacturing, and advanced industrial applications. Executive Order No. 122 offers an opportunity to narrow that gap.

Signed on August 18, 2026, EO 122 establishes a national policy framework for developing the critical minerals industry. Long overdue but welcome, it seeks to expand domestic capacity and move the Philippines further along the value chain.

The policy comes at an opportune moment. Under its Stated Policies Scenario, the International Energy Agency projects that global demand for critical minerals will nearly double by 2040. Lithium demand is expected to more than triple, while demand for nickel, graphite, and magnet rare earths could grow by 50 to 90 percent as economies expand electric vehicles, battery storage, renewable energy, and electricity networks.

EO 122 directs the Department of Environment and Natural Resources, in consultation with the Mining Industry Coordinating Council, to prepare the Philippine Critical Minerals List. The list should reflect the country’s geology, industrial capabilities, import dependencies, recycling capacity, secondary-resource potential, national security requirements, and development goals. It should also complement existing government strategies, including the Philippine Iron and Steel Industry Roadmap 2026–2040 and the Renewable Energy Roadmap 2017–2040.

The government may also consider whether—and how—to distinguish critical minerals from strategic minerals in the Philippine context. Nickel, copper, gold, and iron differ in their uses, markets, supply risks, and value chains. Classification should therefore guide mineral-specific policies for exploration, production, processing, recycling, trade and investment. The list must become an instrument of industrial policy, not simply an inventory of resources.

Nickel illustrates the scale of the opportunity. The Philippines remained the world’s second-largest producer of mined nickel in 2025, accounting for approximately 10 percent of global production. Industry data indicate that China received about 66 percent of Philippine nickel-ore exports, down from 78 percent in 2024 as Indonesia increased its purchases.

Yet the country has only two operating hydrometallurgical nickel-processing plants and most Philippine nickel ore is exported without substantial domestic processing. Even these plants produce intermediate nickel-cobalt products that undergo further refining abroad.

The Philippine Nickel Industry Association welcomed EO 122 as a pivotal step toward advancing the industry and strengthening the country’s position in an increasingly competitive market. The Chamber of Mines of the Philippines likewise emphasized that attracting long-term capital for exploration, mine development and processing requires policy stability and a predictable investment environment.

Both points are well taken. Mineral processing requires patient capital, reliable ore supplies, affordable electricity, infrastructure, technical expertise, and regulations that investors can expect to remain stable across administrations.

EO 122 directs the Department of Trade and Industry and the Board of Investments to promote value-adding critical-mineral investments. This effort must look beyond processing plants. Processors depend on mines, logistics, power, laboratories, and other supporting industries.

The critical-minerals entry in the 2026 Strategic Investment Priority Plan covers the processing of strategic and critical minerals into higher-value products. Future plans should extend appropriate incentives to qualified upstream and supporting activities directly linked to domestic processing, particularly ore suppliers serving certified critical-minerals projects.

The design of those incentives also matters. In a September 2026 report, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development observed that the Philippines could consider expenditure-based incentives, including accelerated depreciation and enhanced deductions. Such incentives are generally more effective at generating additional investment and can provide better value for forgone government revenue.

These measures are especially suited to mineral-processing projects, which require substantial upfront expenditure and face high energy costs and long payback periods. Improving cash flow during the investment and recovery stages may prove more useful than a tax holiday whose value arises only after a project becomes profitable.

Foreign equity entering the sector nevertheless remains modest. Preliminary Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas data show that mining and quarrying accounted for 1.49 percent of net foreign direct-investment equity capital other than reinvested earnings from January through July 2026. Although this measure excludes reinvested earnings, intercompany lending and domestic capital, it illustrates the sector’s limited share of new foreign equity.

To attract investment in exploration, processing, and supporting infrastructure, the Philippines must offer more than mineral deposits. It must offer regulatory certainty.

That certainty begins with efficient permitting. EO 122 directs the DENR and the Mines and Geosciences Bureau to streamline procedures, process permits and clearances simultaneously, and establish a fully digital virtual one-stop shop. Digitalization, however, must be accompanied by firm timelines, the elimination of redundant requirements, and a designated lead agency empowered to issue a definitive government determination.

Environmental review, public consultation, and free, prior, and informed consent remain essential but should not become indefinite. Once all legal requirements are satisfied, national-priority projects should not face duplicative or conflicting demands from other government offices.

EO 122 also arrives as the Philippines seeks a larger role in secure technology supply chains. The country joined the United States-led Pax Silica initiative in April 2026, covering critical minerals, semiconductors, advanced manufacturing, computing, and data infrastructure. However, the country should avoid anchoring its policy to any single foreign partnership.

China remains the largest market for Philippine nickel ore, while the US, Japan, South Korea, Canada, Australia, and the European Union are seeking more diversified supplies. This competition creates bargaining power only if the Philippines has a coherent strategy. Partnerships should be judged by what they deliver: investment, technology transfer, workforce development, responsible sourcing, domestic processing, and dependable markets—not diplomatic alignment alone.

Mineral development must also retain public legitimacy. Processing more minerals at home is not progress if it merely relocates pollution, displaces communities or leaves host areas with inadequate benefits. Environmental protection, mine rehabilitation, worker safety, Indigenous Peoples’ rights, and meaningful community participation are conditions for a durable industry.

EO 122 is a beginning. Possessing minerals is not the same as possessing a minerals industry. Value comes from combining resources with technology, infrastructure, capital, skilled workers, credible regulation, and strategic patience.

The Philippines has taken the first step. The test is whether it can turn the minerals beneath its soil into industrial capabilities that remain above ground—long after the last shipment of ore has left the mine.

November 03, 2026

Critical minerals offer the Philippines an opportunity to connect its geological resources with industrial development, energy security and technological change. Realizing that opportunity requires more than identifying deposits or increasing ore exports. It requires reliable resource information, commercially viable processing, dependable infrastructure and institutions that protect the environment and affected communities. The country’s emerging policy framework should therefore be judged by its ability to turn mineral potential into lasting domestic capabilities. 

Understanding what makes a mineral critical 

Criticality depends on the needs and vulnerabilities of a particular economy. A mineral may be important because it supports strategic industries, because its supply is exposed to disruption, or because its production creates significant opportunities for national development. Geological abundance alone does not establish criticality. Neither does inclusion in another country’s list. A producing country such as the Philippines must consider both the value of its resources and the risks that may prevent it from benefiting from them. 

Executive Order No. 122, signed on 18 August 2026, defines critical minerals by their importance to clean energy technologies, advanced manufacturing, digital infrastructure, national defense and other strategic industries. This definition places mining within a broader development agenda. Copper can support electrical infrastructure; nickel and associated cobalt can contribute to selected battery supply chains; other mineral products serve manufacturing and construction. The relevant question is how each resource can support Philippine priorities at an economically and environmentally acceptable cost. 

A national list grounded in Philippine conditions 

The proposed DENR administrative order dated 10 September 2026 would designate gold, nickel and associated cobalt and scandium, copper and associated molybdenum, iron, chromium, limestone and silica as critical minerals. This is a proposed list in the supplied draft, rather than an adopted list established by that document. Its inclusion of industrial minerals reflects a development approach extending beyond batteries and the minerals most often associated with the energy transition. 

The draft assessment combines economic importance and opportunities, producer and supply-chain risks, and strategic importance and demand. It also proposes comprehensive review every three years, with interim reviews when circumstances materially change. This flexibility is useful because technologies, markets and national industrial needs evolve. To make the system credible, the government should publish the evidence, assumptions and reasoning supporting inclusion or removal. Assessment should also recognize emerging opportunities that may be undervalued when scoring relies heavily on existing production and exports. 

Implementing Executive Order No 122 

EO No. 122 establishes a national policy framework and reorganizes the Mining Industry Coordinating Council. It directs national exploration and mineral reservation initiatives, stricter enforcement of development obligations, accelerated disposition of government-owned critical mineral mining assets, digitalized permitting and investment promotion across the mineral value chain. Its guiding principles combine State ownership and economic development with environmental protection, community development and a stable investment environment. These commitments need to operate together. 

The order considers critical mineral projects national priority projects. That policy status should be implemented through clear administrative procedures consistent with governing laws. A mineral’s strategic importance does not resolve questions about land rights, environmental impacts, indigenous rights or technical feasibility. The proposed DAO would introduce project certification and endorsement procedures tied to valid permits or rights and compliance with pertinent laws. Final guidelines should clearly distinguish mineral designation, project certification, permit approval and eligibility for investment incentives. 

The order’s “use it or lose it” policy targets material non-compliance with approved timelines, work programs or development commitments, while recognizing valid justification involving force majeure or causes beyond a contractor’s control. Effective implementation requires objective criteria and fair procedures. Authorities should distinguish speculative retention of tenements from genuine delays caused by unresolved approvals, access constraints or other documented circumstances. Predictable enforcement can encourage development while reducing avoidable disputes. 

The virtual one-stop shop is another important reform. EO No. 122 directs simultaneous processing, clear timelines and performance accountability, followed by an integrated digital platform linking national and local permitting systems. Digitalization will be useful only if agencies also reconcile information requirements, responsibilities and conflicting records. A portal that merely receives applications while unresolved coordination problems persist would have limited practical value. 

Making domestic processing commercially viable 

Value addition is central to the order. It calls for refining, advanced material processing and downstream manufacturing, supported by energy, water, logistics, recovery and recycling activities. It also provides for priority access by domestic processing plants to ores at fair, market-based prices using transparent benchmarks and allowable adjustments. Implementing rules should explain how this priority will work alongside existing supply arrangements and the requirements of different processing technologies. 

Processing investments depend on ore characteristics, reliable feedstock, energy costs, water availability, transport, waste management and market access. Government support should follow project-specific feasibility analysis and measurable development benefits. Shared infrastructure, technology partnerships and predictable administration may be as important as fiscal incentives. Policies affecting ore exports should be carefully sequenced with actual processing capacity, so that the transition supports viable investment and the livelihoods dependent on existing operations. 

However, processing is a stage of production; domestic value capture is an economic outcome. A plant can increase the value of exports while relying heavily on imported technology, equipment, inputs and services. The national gain must be assessed after accounting for those costs and public assistance. 

This distinction should shape incentives. Before supporting a project, government should ask what additional benefit the assistance purchases, how long support will be needed and what happens if promised outcomes fail to materialize. Conditions could cover workforce training, competitive local procurement, environmental performance and knowledge transfer. Support should have review dates and proportionate remedies. Otherwise, the country risks replacing dependence on ore exports with dependence on permanently assisted processing facilities. 

Nickel as a test of responsible value addition 

The Responsible Nickel Roadmap for the Philippines provides a practical framework for connecting industrial ambition with responsible resource management. Organized around the United Nations Resource Management System principles, it addresses governance, integrated resource management, value addition, comprehensive recovery, circularity, innovation, environmental responsibility, social engagement, transparency, health and safety, and institutional capability. Its recommendations should be understood as a roadmap for action, rather than evidence that the proposed measures have already been implemented. 

For nickel laterites, processing choices must reflect mineralogy and ore variability. High-pressure acid leaching, other leaching methods and ferronickel production serve different feedstocks and markets, with different infrastructure needs and environmental implications. The roadmap recommends comparing processing routes against Philippine conditions, including power costs, logistics and environmental performance. This approach supports investment decisions based on actual deposit characteristics and operating conditions. 

Comprehensive recovery offers another opportunity. Nickel deposits may contain cobalt, scandium, chromium and other potentially valuable components. Their presence does not establish that recovery is technically or commercially feasible. Mineralogical characterization, laboratory testing, pilot work and market analysis are needed to establish recoverability and product quality. The whole-deposit approach should also examine residues and potential liabilities, so that higher recovery does not create unmanaged waste or misleading expectations about resource value. 

Research that reaches industrial application 

The Mining and Minerals Sector R&D Roadmap for Critical Minerals for 2022–2028 identifies research pathways covering mineral extraction, characterization, refining and recovery from secondary materials. It includes work on metallic and non-metallic resources, mine tailings and wastes, spent batteries and other novel sources. Laboratory facilities and trained personnel are integral to the roadmap. These activities can broaden the country’s options beyond the export of unprocessed materials. 

Research milestones, however, should be distinguished from demonstrated commercial performance. A laboratory extraction result does not by itself establish a bankable processing plant. Public support should help promising technologies move through independent validation, pilot operation, product qualification and commercial assessment. Evaluation should include reagent and energy consumption, water use, residue stability, production cost and buyer acceptance. Industry participation can help define realistic specifications and identify practical barriers early. 

Circularity also deserves a place in mineral policy. Recovery from spent batteries, scrap, tailings and other residues may improve resource efficiency and reduce some waste burdens. Its contribution depends on collection systems, material volumes, safe handling and suitable technology. A circular economy strategy should connect research with standards, logistics and responsible end-of-life management. It should complement carefully managed primary production while avoiding assumptions that every waste stream is a recoverable resource. 

Safeguards as conditions for durable investment 

EO No. 122 directs simultaneous permitting, clearer timelines and an integrated digital platform. These reforms can remove avoidable delay. Their value, however, depends on the quality of decisions made through them. A faster permit issued on conflicting land records or incomplete environmental information may lead to disputes, financing problems and costly redesign. Timeliness should be measured alongside the reliability of approvals and the resolution of material issues. 

The “use it or lose it” policy raises a related question of accountability. The order targets material non-compliance with development obligations while recognizing specified valid justifications. Fair implementation requires evidence of the contractor’s obligations and the reasons for delay. Government should also disclose delays attributable to its own processes. Enforcement gains legitimacy when private proponents and public agencies are both held to clear responsibilities. Supplemental procedures should preserve applicable legal protections while making decisions predictable. 

Responsible development requires attention to cumulative impacts, water systems, biodiversity, climate hazards and mine closure. The nickel roadmap recommends reconciling land-use information, integrating relevant boundaries and geological data, and incorporating disaster and climate risk across the mining lifecycle. These proposals can improve early screening and reduce uncertainty. Shared information must be accurate and developed with appropriate participation by communities and rights holders. 

For projects affecting ancestral domains, indigenous rights and applicable free, prior and informed consent requirements must be addressed within the relevant legal framework. Participation should enable communities to understand proposed activities, benefits, risks and long-term obligations. Clear commitments, accessible grievance mechanisms and transparent monitoring help sustain trust after approvals are secured. Community development and rehabilitation costs should be reflected in project economics from the outset. 

The nickel roadmap’s emphasis on integrated land information, climate hazards, social engagement and environmental performance is therefore central to the investment proposition. These concerns affect whether a project can operate reliably over decades, rather than merely obtain initial approval. 

Turning the framework into measurable results 

The next step is an implementation program with named agencies, realistic funding and measurable outcomes. Progress should be assessed through reliable resource information, timely and legally sound permit decisions, viable processing investments, domestic supplier participation, workforce development and verified environmental and social performance. Public reporting should explain delays and corrective action. Mineral criticality should guide policy attention while project decisions remain grounded in evidence and applicable requirements. 

The Philippines has a policy opportunity to align mining, industrial development and responsible resource management. Its success will depend on coordinated implementation and commercially sound choices. A critical minerals strategy should leave the country with stronger technical institutions, greater industrial capability and tangible benefits for host communities. Those outcomes will provide a more meaningful measure of progress than the length of a minerals list or the volume of ore exported. The most revealing question is what a host region can sustain when extraction ends. 

Critical minerals provide the Philippines with choices, not a guaranteed development path. EO No. 122 and the accompanying roadmaps can support industrial progress if implementation remains evidence-based and accountable. The country should demand more than additional tons, facilities or diplomatic announcements. It should demand an economy that learns, enterprises that become competitive and communities that gain durable security. Mineral wealth is depleted through extraction; the policy succeeds when the capabilities created in return continue to grow.

 

Fernando “Ronnie” S. Penarroyo specializes in Energy and Resources Law, Project Finance and Business Development. He is also currently the Chair of the Professional Regulatory Board of Geology, the government agency mandated under law to regulate and develop the geology profession. For any matters or inquiries in relation to the Philippine resources industry and suggested topics for commentaries, he may be contacted at fspenarroyo@penpalaw.com. Atty. Penarroyo’s commentaries are also archived at his professional blogsite at www.penarroyo.com 

 

References 

DENR–MGB. Proposed DAO on the Philippine Critical Minerals List, 10 September 2026, sections 5–10 and Annex A. 

Department of Science and Technology–Philippine Council for Industry, Energy and Emerging Technology Research and Development (DOST–PCIEERD). (n.d.). Mining and minerals sector R&D roadmap for critical minerals (2022–2028) [Roadmap infographic]. 

Halkes, R. T., Delina-Agillon, R. E., Mills, E., Shaw, I. R., de Jongh, M., Lacinska, A., Winson, A., & Goodenough, K. M. (2026). Responsible nickel roadmap for the Philippines. British Geological Survey. 

Republic of the Philippines. Executive Order No. 122, 18 August 2026. 

November 03, 2026

Much of the Philippines’ mineral wealth sits inside ancestral domains. Where it does, the Indigenous Peoples’ Rights Act (RA 8371) requires the Free, Prior and Informed Consent (FPIC) of the affected Indigenous Cultural Communities and Indigenous Peoples before any concession, license, permit, lease, or production-sharing agreement is granted or renewed.  

On 04 May 2026, the National Commission on Indigenous Peoples (NCIP) Commission En Banc approved NCIP Administrative Order No. 3, Series of 2026, otherwise known as the “2026 FPIC Guidelines”, replacing the 2012  Guidelines. 

The 2026 FPIC Guidelines were published in the Official Gazette on 28 September 2026 and took effect 15 days thereafter, or on 14 October 2026. 

The Indigenous People’s Rights Act (“IPRA”) or Republic Act 8371 itself has not changed.  Consent still belongs to the community, customary law continues to govern every stage, and a non-diminution clause bars the diminution of any right already recognized under the Constitution, IPRA, or jurisprudence. What has changed is how the FPIC process runs: it is now said to be clearer, time-bound, and more accountable. 

The 2026 FPIC Guidelines are prospective in application.  If an FPIC process is currently underway, the same shall continue under the 2012 Guidelines, but the community and the applicant may expressly agree to be covered by the new rules. 

Key Changes 

Projects are now sorted into Category A, B, or C. Category A covers mineral agreements and natural resource contracts, i.e., MPSAs, FTAAs, large-scale metallic and non-metallic agreements, and industrial sand-and-gravel permits managed by the national government. In Category A, the Certification Precondition (CP) is issued by the Commission En Banc itself.  

Category B covers exploration permits, small-scale quarrying, and small-scale mining in a declared Minahang Bayan, with the CP issued by the Regional Director.  

Category C is for community-driven, non-commercial initiatives. 

The 2012 rules did not set fixed deadlines, and the process could drag on indefinitely. To address this, the 2026 FPIC Guidelines introduce fixed timelines. For Category A, community assemblies finish within 10 days, consensus and decision-making run up to 60 days, MOA negotiation takes 10 days, and validation and signing another 5.  Category B exploration moves on a 5-7-2-2 schedule.  

These timelines are not meant to rush the community. Under Section 54 of the 2026 FPIC Guidelines, the community and the applicant may agree in writing to extend the periods. If the periods lapse without a signed MOA, the Guidelines treat that as a denial of consent. 

Section 87 clarifies that an exploration permit confers no vested right, priority, or expectation of development approval.  Proceeding to development requires a fresh FPIC process and a separate agreement. 

There is no automatic renewal.  Renewal requires FPIC and must begin at least three years before expiry. The CP is non-transferable, and a CP left dormant for a year may be canceled after a show-cause order. 

The Guidelines also introduce the Exercise of Priority Rights (EPR) whereby communities must formulate their own EPR Plans to guide how they manage and prioritize their resources. Sacred grounds, burial sites, and reserved areas are excluded from any project activity, and the Guidelines allow for joint ventures, community equity, and contractor or operator arrangements. 

Perennial Issues 

For local government units, the Guidelines represent only one side of a three-party arrangement: the community gives consent, the state runs the process, but the host LGU lives with the results, possibly for decades.  

The LGUs’ recurring grievance is less about consent than about delivery.  Host municipalities have struggled to receive their share of national mining revenues, prompting calls for direct remittance or escrow. The 2026 FPIC Guidelines also leave unresolved whose decision prevails when an LGU’s development plan and an ancestral domain’s choice point in opposite directions, and who, over the life of a project, can enforce a consent framed as a continuing obligation. 

For the Anti-Red Tape Authority (ARTA), the Guidelines may run counter to the ease-of-doing-business regime ARTA administers. ARTA’s stated aim is streamlining without shortcutting consent, separating genuine red tape from the time consent legitimately needs. Under ease-of-doing-business rules, a missed processing deadline can result in automatic approval. On the other hand, the 2026 FPIC Guidelines take the opposite approach: if the FPIC periods lapse without a signed MOA, consent is deemed denied. 

ARTA’s work on a model ordinance to standardize LGU mining requirements also raises the question of how standardization avoids overriding legitimate local conditions. 

These issues raise the question of whether the government, as owner of the minerals and principal to the mining companies that act as its contractors, is doing enough to close these gaps. Mining activity has picked up in recent years, and the Philippines is now a focal point in global critical mineral supply chains. More than ever, investors need assurance that our mining policies are stable and that the government will actively support the sector. 

Opposition  

The 2026 FPIC Guidelines have drawn organized opposition. Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International Philippines, Kalikasan, and the Indigenous Peoples Law and Policy Program argue that the compressed timelines sit over customary, consensus-based decision-making. They allege that a Certificate of Non-Overlap can now be issued from documents alone, without the field investigation the 2012 Guidelines required, even where an overlap is alleged.   

Critics also fault the drafting itself, claiming that only one public forum was held over a four-year process, with 170-plus Indigenous and civil society organizations saying their input was not significantly incorporated. In the House of Representatives, House Resolution No. 1345 was filed to probe alleged flaws and irregularities within the FPIC process. 

Managing the transition 

For the mining industry, a productive way to use the 2026 Guidelines is to treat the shorter process as an incentive to prepare more and better, rather than simply a way to secure consent faster. The Guidelines compress the timelines and shift much of the documentation burden onto proponents. Consent obtained through a rushed process will be the first to be challenged, especially given the aforementioned opposition. 

The shorter periods for convening the assembly and reaching consensus on large-scale projects leave little room to build trust within the formal process, so much of that work has to be done before the clock starts. Proponents should engage the community early and informally and prepare project information in the local language. They should also confirm which Indigenous Political Structure NCIP recognizes, and check for overlaps with ancestral domains against NCIP’s updated shapefiles and the FPIC Transparency Portal. 

At a time when the Guidelines’ legitimacy is under close scrutiny, mining and exploration companies may consider voluntary measures to ensure a meaningful and legitimate process.  This would be the industry’s best answer to critics who say the reforms favor business alone. 

October 15, 2026

There is, apparently, one reliable way to get people to drive less: start a war near the oil. 

That is not an energy policy. It is just the sort of grotesque lesson modern conflict keeps teaching with terrible efficiency. In March, the International Energy Agency urged governments and households to cope with rising fuel prices by doing the very things climate advocates have been pleading for years: work from home when possible, avoid unnecessary flights, slow down on highways, and take public transport. Six months later, the vulnerability behind that advice remains. Reuters reported on September 22 that Saudi Arabia’s East-West oil pipeline had restarted after a drone attack forced its closure earlier in the month. Even the route used to bypass the Strait of Hormuz had proved vulnerable. 

And that is where the bitter comedy begins. 

In peacetime, if you suggest that maybe we should fly less, drive less, burn less, and generally stop treating the atmosphere like an ashtray with weather, people call it moral vanity. Elitist. Anti-growth. Anti-car. Anti-fun. Suggest biking and someone will act as though you have proposed monasticism. Tell people to take the bus and they look at you as if you have personally outlawed joy. 

But let missiles land near refineries. Let shipping routes wobble. Let prices climb until every trip to the gas station feels like a mugging with receipt paper. Then, suddenly, restraint becomes sensible. Even patriotic. What years of environmental argument could not make attractive, war can make unavoidable in a week. 

War, in other words, is a very effective conservation campaign. Its problem is branding. Also, the blood. 

The irony has a limit, of course. Burning less because a journey has become unaffordable is a measure of hardship, not necessarily of environmental progress. A family skipping a trip, a driver losing passengers, a household stretching its cooking fuel: these are people absorbing a shock. Any honest accounting must distinguish the fuel saved from the life diminished. 

That is only one obscenity among many. The larger dishonesty is the way war is still described in the inflated vocabulary of action and force: targets struck, positions taken, deterrence restored, capabilities degraded. The verbs are always so proud of themselves. They sound fine on a lectern. They sound less fine beside a darkened hospital, an empty tap, a dead refrigerator, a pharmacy with no power, or a child with diarrhoea because the pipes gave out three weeks ago. In March, International Committee of the Red Cross President Mirjana Spoljaric said it plainly: “War on essential infrastructure is war on civilians.” That sentence is so clinically worded it almost hides the cruelty inside it. Almost. 

Because that is what war does when it outgrows the battlefield. It does not just kill people. It damages the conditions that let people go on being people. It turns ordinary life into a chain of failing systems. One blown transformer becomes spoiled medicine. A damaged water line becomes disease. A fuel shortage becomes a stalled ambulance. A crater is never just a crater for long. It becomes a timetable. 

Take Tehran. In March, strikes on oil facilities sent toxic plumes over the capital. The World Health Organization warned about the health risks from toxic air and “black rain.” There is something especially sinister about that phrase. It sounds poetic until one remembers that poetry is not supposed to burn your lungs. A city does not have to be flattened to be attacked. Sometimes it is enough to make the air itself untrustworthy. 

Gaza shows how destruction keeps working after the strike itself. In September, a war-damaged apartment building collapsed on families sheltering inside. Reuters reported that at least 20 people, including children, had been killed. Rescuers searched the wreckage without adequate machinery. Families had taken shelter in damaged buildings because safer alternatives were scarce. A damaged building is not simply a record of what happened. For people with nowhere else to live, it is a danger still unfolding. 

The rubble is both an environmental burden and the remains of homes. Reporting this month continued to cite a United Nations estimate of roughly 61 million tonnes of wreckage and debris. The number describes a landscape through which people must still find shelter, reach help and attempt to live. War begins with fire and noise. Its aftermath can kill without either. 

Ukraine tells the same story in a colder, more industrial register. Its devastation also raises a question that survives every damaged building: What will it take to put this back? Reconstruction requires materials, transport, and energy. War’s carbon account extends beyond the fuel burned by military vehicles and the smoke from the targets they strike. First the missile. Then the cement mixer. First the fire. Then the diesel-powered recovery plan. It is the circular economy, if the circular economy were run by arsonists. 

And then comes the insult dressed up as wisdom. Officials return to the old conservation sermon, now delivered with the urgency of a fuel shortage. The sermon was never wrong. It is just that, in peacetime, people found it easier to sneer at than to practise. Peace asks nicely and gets mocked for nagging. War imposes the lesson with a crater. 

For the Philippines, this is not a remote morality tale performed somewhere else for the benefit of experts with maps. It arrives in familiar domestic scenes. The LPG tank gets heavier in the imagination before it gets lighter in the hand. The tricycle driver does the math twice. The delivery fee changes the price of dinner. The cashier says the total and there is that small pause—that quiet Filipino pause—when you pretend you are not surprised because surprise is not legal tender. 

In April, the government announced the suspension of taxes on kerosene and LPG to cushion households. Such relief recognizes how quickly a distant war can rearrange the contents of a Filipino kitchen. The harder question is what we build beyond emergency relief: public transport people can rely on, streets where walking and cycling are safe, and working arrangements that spare an unnecessary commute. 

It is easy to advise people to take a bus if you never have to wait for one. A tricycle driver cannot work from home. A worker cannot cycle safely through a road designed as though cyclists were a clerical error. Conservation becomes credible public policy when people have practical ways to practise it. Otherwise, the advice asks households to solve, through personal sacrifice, what governments have failed to make possible. 

We are an archipelago, but not nearly as insulated as the word sounds. 

This is why the environmental cost of war should stop being treated as a side issue, a soft concern, a specialist’s footnote to the “real” business of geopolitics. It is one of war’s main products. Armies count advances, sorties, and payloads. The earth counts smoke, contaminated rubble, poisoned water, ruined harvests, stressed power grids, disease outbreaks, and carbon loads. One ledger is made for the press briefing. The other is made for the next century. 

War’s harshest indecency is that it can make societies look more “sustainable” only by first making the world less habitable. 

 

Atty. Noel B. Lazaro is Chief Legal Counsel and Keziah Aizelle P. Sy is Research Associate at Global Ferronickel Holdings, Inc. Gian Paolo M. Comia is a law student at the Ateneo de Manila University School of Law. Their team has been named In-House Team of the Year by Asian Legal Business–Southeast Asia and Legal Team of the Year by the In-House Community. 

 

 

August 27, 2026

Pax Silica is a U.S.-led initiative launched in late 2025 to establish a trusted network of partner countries across the artificial intelligence (AI) and semiconductor value chain, from critical mineral extraction and energy infrastructure to semiconductor manufacturing, data centers, and AI technologies. Named from the Latin word pax ("peace" or "stable order") and silica (silicon dioxide, the primary source of silicon used in semiconductor chips), the initiative envisions a stable international economic order built on secure and resilient technology supply chains. Designed to strengthen resilient technology supply chains and reduce dependence on geographically concentrated production—particularly in China—it seeks to secure critical minerals, ensure reliable energy, expand trusted semiconductor manufacturing, strengthen AI infrastructure, diversify supply chains, and coordinate strategic investments among partner economies. 

Pax Silica has also emerged as one of the more controversial policy initiatives following President Ferdinand R. Marcos Jr.'s endorsement of the project in his 2026 State of the Nation Address. While the administration has presented the initiative as a transformative opportunity to position the Philippines as a regional hub for artificial intelligence, semiconductors, and advanced manufacturing, it has also sparked public debate over its long-term implications. Supporters view Pax Silica as a strategic pathway to attract high-value investments, accelerate industrialization, and strengthen the country's role in global technology supply chains. Critics, however, question whether the initiative could deepen foreign influence over the Philippines' strategic minerals, energy resources, and critical infrastructure, while raising concerns about environmental impacts, indigenous communities, national security, and whether Filipinos will capture a fair share of the economic value created. These competing perspectives underscore that the success of Pax Silica will depend not only on the scale of investment it attracts but also on the legal, regulatory, and governance frameworks that ensure the country's natural resources and strategic industries advance long-term national interests. 

The Philippines has emerged as a key prospective participant in the initiative. The Philippine and U.S. governments are working toward a framework agreement, with Foxconn expected to become the first locator at the AI and semiconductor hub in New Clark City. The initiative has also attracted support from the U.S. International Development Finance Corporation, Amazon Web Services, and the U.S. Millennium Challenge Corporation through proposed investments in digital infrastructure, energy security, and the Luzon Economic Corridor. These developments reinforce the country's ambition to become a regional hub for AI, semiconductor manufacturing, and advanced digital infrastructure. 

For the Philippines, Pax Silica has profound implications for the mining and energy sectors, which supply the critical minerals and reliable power required by the digital economy. The country's abundant nickel, copper, gold, chromite, and renewable energy resources—particularly geothermal energy—position it to become an important participant in global technology supply chains. However, realizing these opportunities will require policies that promote domestic value addition, responsible resource management, environmental sustainability, and long-term national development rather than simply facilitating foreign investment. 

The Strategic Importance of Philippine Mining 

Mining has traditionally been viewed as an extractive industry supplying raw materials to foreign manufacturers. Under Pax Silica, however, mining assumes a strategic dimension because critical minerals have become essential inputs to the global digital economy. 

Nickel, for example, is no longer merely an industrial metal. It is now fundamental to battery technology, data center energy storage systems, semiconductor manufacturing equipment, and electric vehicles. Likewise, copper is indispensable for electrical transmission, semiconductor fabrication equipment, renewable energy systems, and AI infrastructure. As demand for these technologies expands, so too does the strategic importance of countries capable of supplying these resources. 

For decades, the Philippines has largely exported raw nickel ore, much of which is processed overseas before being incorporated into higher-value products. Consequently, the country captures only a small fraction of the total value generated throughout the technology supply chain. Pax Silica presents an opportunity to reverse this historical pattern by encouraging domestic mineral processing, refining, precursor chemical production, and integration into semiconductor manufacturing. 

Instead of remaining merely an exporter of mineral resources, the Philippines could participate in multiple stages of the technology value chain. Such industrial upgrading would generate higher incomes, increase technological capabilities, and reduce dependence on commodity exports whose prices fluctuate significantly in global markets. 

Industrial Transformation Rather Than Resource Extraction 

Perhaps the greatest opportunity presented by Pax Silica lies in shifting Philippine mining policy from extraction toward industrialization. Historically, many developing economies have experienced what economists describe as the "resource curse," wherein abundant natural resources generate export revenues without fostering sustainable industrial development. The Philippines risks repeating this pattern if mining expansion merely increases exports of unprocessed ore. 

Participation in Pax Silica should therefore be conditioned upon policies that require greater domestic value addition. Mineral processing facilities, battery precursor plants, high-value semiconductor material manufacturing, and advanced metallurgical industries should accompany expanded mining activities. These downstream industries create significantly more employment, generate higher tax revenues, stimulate research and development, and encourage technology transfer. 

Without such industrial policies, Pax Silica could merely reinforce existing patterns in which foreign firms extract Philippine resources while capturing most of the economic value through overseas manufacturing and intellectual property ownership. 

The Energy Sector as the Foundation of Pax Silica 

While mining supplies the raw materials, energy provides the foundation upon which the entire Pax Silica ecosystem depends. Modern semiconductor fabrication plants require uninterrupted electricity twenty-four hours a day with exceptionally high-power quality. Voltage fluctuations lasting only milliseconds may destroy millions of dollars' worth of semiconductor wafers. Likewise, AI data centers consume extraordinary quantities of electricity for computing and cooling systems. 

This presents both opportunities and challenges for the Philippine energy sector. The country's substantial geothermal resources offer a significant competitive advantage. Unlike solar and wind generation, geothermal energy provides stable baseload electricity independent of weather conditions. Such reliability is particularly attractive for semiconductor manufacturing and AI facilities that cannot tolerate interruptions in power supply. 

Consequently, Pax Silica could substantially increase demand for geothermal development, creating opportunities for additional steam fields, power plants, and associated transmission infrastructure. Long-term electricity requirements may also increase demand for sophisticated steam supply agreements and project implementation arrangements that provide investors with contractual certainty over several decades. 

While geothermal energy offers a natural competitive advantage, nuclear energy may also become an important component of the long-term energy mix required to support Pax Silica. Semiconductor fabrication plants and hyperscale AI data centers require continuous, high-capacity baseload electricity that intermittent renewable sources alone may not consistently provide. The Philippine government's renewed interest in nuclear energy—including the possible deployment of small modular reactors (SMRs)—could therefore complement geothermal generation by providing reliable, carbon-free electricity capable of supporting energy-intensive industries. If implemented under robust safety, environmental, and regulatory frameworks, nuclear power could strengthen the country's energy security while reducing dependence on imported fossil fuels and helping achieve its decarbonization objectives. 

Hydrogen, particularly white (natural) hydrogen, also represents a potentially transformative energy resource for the future Pax Silica ecosystem. Unlike green hydrogen, which is produced through electrolysis using renewable electricity, white hydrogen occurs naturally in geological formations and can potentially be extracted directly from the subsurface with significantly lower production costs and carbon emissions. Although commercial development remains at an early stage globally and the existence of economically recoverable deposits in the Philippines has yet to be established, ongoing exploration suggests that naturally occurring hydrogen could emerge as a strategic energy resource. If viable deposits are identified, white hydrogen could provide low-carbon fuel for industrial processes, backup power generation, hydrogen fuel cells, and future clean manufacturing applications associated with semiconductor production and AI infrastructure. Given the Philippines' active tectonic setting and extensive geothermal systems, the country may warrant further geological assessment to evaluate the potential occurrence of natural hydrogen resources. 

Risks of Rising Energy Costs 

Despite these opportunities, significant risks remain. The Philippines already has some of the highest electricity prices in Southeast Asia. Energy-intensive industries such as semiconductor manufacturing require globally competitive electricity prices to remain economically viable. If generation capacity does not expand sufficiently, increasing industrial demand could place additional pressure on electricity prices for households and other industries. 

Moreover, the substantial public investment required for transmission networks, substations, industrial parks, and power generation may impose significant fiscal burdens if not carefully planned. Policymakers must therefore ensure that investments serving strategic industries also strengthen the broader national electricity system rather than creating isolated infrastructure benefiting only a limited number of multinational corporations. 

Environmental Sustainability and Responsible Mining 

Any expansion of mining inevitably raises environmental concerns. Critical mineral extraction can generate deforestation, biodiversity loss, watershed degradation, sedimentation, acid mine drainage, and increased greenhouse gas emissions if environmental safeguards are inadequately enforced. Many mineral deposits are located within environmentally sensitive regions and indigenous ancestral domains, further complicating project development. 

Consequently, environmental governance must become an integral component of any Philippine participation in Pax Silica. Mining companies should be required to implement internationally recognized environmental management systems, progressive rehabilitation programs, transparent monitoring mechanisms, and comprehensive mine closure plans. Likewise, the principles of Free and Prior Informed Consent (FPIC) should be rigorously observed whenever projects affect indigenous communities. 

Semiconductor fabrication plants and hyperscale data centers are also among the most water-intensive industrial facilities in the world. Semiconductor manufacturing requires ultra-pure water (UPW) for wafer cleaning, chemical processing, and contamination control, with a single fabrication plant consuming millions of liters of water daily. Likewise, large data centers require substantial volumes of water for cooling systems, particularly in facilities that rely on evaporative cooling technologies. As Pax Silica encourages the development of semiconductor manufacturing and AI infrastructure in the Philippines, policymakers must recognize that water security will become as strategically important as energy security. Industrial expansion should therefore be accompanied by integrated water resource management, including sustainable groundwater regulation, watershed protection, wastewater recycling, rainwater harvesting, and investments in advanced water treatment and reuse technologies. Without careful planning, increased industrial demand could intensify competition for water among households, agriculture, and industry, particularly during periods of drought or in water-stressed regions. Ensuring reliable and sustainable water supplies will thus be essential not only for maintaining industrial competitiveness but also for protecting environmental sustainability and safeguarding the country's long-term water security. 

Failure to maintain high environmental standards risks undermining the social legitimacy of Pax Silica while imposing long-term ecological costs that exceed short-term economic gains. 

Legal and Regulatory Challenges 

Successful participation in Pax Silica will require significant reforms across multiple legal sectors. Mining legislation may need revision to encourage downstream processing while maintaining environmental safeguards. Investment regulations must balance foreign participation with protection of strategic national assets. Energy regulation must facilitate long-term infrastructure investments while preserving affordability and reliability. 

Equally important are legal frameworks governing data protection, cybersecurity, competition policy, indigenous peoples' rights, and environmental compliance. Since AI infrastructure and semiconductor facilities constitute critical national infrastructure, regulatory agencies must coordinate economic development objectives with national security considerations. 

Contractual arrangements will likewise become increasingly important. Long-term mineral supply agreements, power purchase agreements, steam supply contracts, infrastructure concessions, and investment agreements must allocate commercial risks fairly while protecting the public interest. Excessively generous incentives or inflexible stabilization clauses may constrain future governments and reduce policy flexibility. 

Economic Governance and Technology Transfer 

One of the greatest concerns surrounding Pax Silica is the possibility that the Philippines may remain confined to lower-value activities while advanced manufacturing, intellectual property, and AI innovation remain concentrated abroad. To avoid this outcome, government policy should prioritize technology transfer, workforce development, domestic research, and local supplier participation. 

Investment agreements should include measurable commitments to develop Filipino human capital and domestic industrial capabilities through the training of local engineers and geoscientists, collaboration with Philippine universities, research partnerships, procurement from domestic suppliers, support for small and medium enterprises, and, where appropriate, technology licensing and transfer. These commitments help ensure that foreign investment strengthens national capabilities and long-term industrial competitiveness rather than merely utilizing Philippine labor and natural resources. 

Conclusion 

Pax Silica offers a rare opportunity to reshape the Philippine economy—advancing industrialization, strengthening energy security, reinforcing semiconductor supply chains, creating high-value employment, and positioning the country at the forefront of the global digital economy. Yet these benefits are far from inevitable and will require deliberate policy choices and strong institutional governance to be realized. Without sound policy and effective governance, the country risks remaining primarily a supplier of critical minerals and low-cost labor while foreign firms capture the greatest value through advanced manufacturing, technology ownership, and intellectual property. Expanding industrial activity also brings challenges, including greater geopolitical exposure, environmental pressures, rising energy and water demand, and substantial infrastructure and fiscal requirements. 

The issue, therefore, is not whether the Philippines should participate in Pax Silica, but how it can do so on terms that promote long-term national development. Achieving this objective will require strong institutions, clear legal and regulatory frameworks, responsible environmental stewardship, competitive and reliable energy systems, meaningful technology transfer, and a coherent industrial policy that fosters domestic value addition. If these conditions are met, Pax Silica could transform the Philippine mining and energy sectors from traditional resource industries into strategic foundations of the country's digital and industrial future. 

 

Fernando “Ronnie” S. Penarroyo specializes in Energy and Resources Law, Project Finance and Business Development. He is also currently the Chair of the Professional Regulatory Board of Geology, the government agency mandated under law to regulate and develop the geology profession. For any matters or inquiries in relation to the Philippine resources industry and suggested topics for commentaries, he may be contacted at fspenarroyo@penpalaw.com. Atty. Penarroyo’s commentaries are also archived at his professional blogsite at www.penarroyo.com 

August 27, 2026

Diwata-Women in Resource Development, Inc. marked its 14th anniversary not by looking inward, but by reaching outward, bringing together communities, institutions, and partners in the spirit of compassion and solidarity. 

On 17 July 2026, in partnership with the South African Embassy, Diwata commemorated Nelson Mandela Day through a community outreach at Magata-Manggahan Elementary School in Sitio Manggahan, Barangay Daraitan, Tanay, Rizal. The initiative reflected the values that defined Mandela’s life and legacy of compassion, equality, dignity, and service to others. 

Nelson Mandela Day is of profound significance for both South Africa and Diwata. Nelson Mandela was the first democratically-elected President of South Africa and is regarded as a hero and a symbol of freedom, peace, and equality.  He put an end to discrimination based on race or skin color in South Africa. This is why we chose to establish Diwata on 18 July 2012, Nelson Mandela Day: because we believe in, and want to live out and uphold, the ideals he fought for. 

In her opening remarks, South Africa Ambassador Bartinah Ntombizodwa Radebe-Netshitenzhe said that more than a celebration of his life, Nelson Mandela Day is a global call to action and a reminder to all that we have the power and responsibility to make a positive change or difference in the lives of others.     

In South Africa, people mark the occasion by performing 67 minutes of service, representing the 67 years that Nelson Mandela dedicated to public service, human rights, and the fight against apartheid. Even simple acts of kindness like mentoring a young person, visiting the elderly, or supporting a neighbor count toward the 67 minutes. 

Set against this backdrop, the outreach at Barangay Daraitan on Nelson Mandela Day became a living expression of what can happen when government, the diplomatic corps, private institutions, development organizations, and civil society come together. 

The event was graced by Rizal Governor Nina Ynares and Tanay Mayor Rex C. Tanjuatco, whose presence underscored the importance of partnerships between local leadership and civic initiatives. We were also joined by representatives from the Embassy of Angola, the Embassy of the People’s Republic of China, and the Consulate of the Democratic Socialist Republic of Sri Lanka in Davao, bringing a strong sense of international solidarity. 

Diwata also received invaluable support from the administrators and faculty of Magata-Manggahan Elementary School, the National Commission on Indigenous Peoples (NCIP), local government volunteers, and many other collaborators on the ground.  

The South African Embassy rallied together an extraordinary network of donors and supporters. Through the South African Embassy’s leadership and commitment to Nelson Mandela’s enduring ideals, assistance poured in from a wide range of institutions, including ICTSI Foundation, Reel Steel Corporation, DigiPlus Foundation, GoTyme Bank, Ethiopian Airlines, Food Access PH, RCBC Realty Corporation, the Department of Foreign Affairs-Office of Middle East and African Affairs, Aspen Philippines, the Philippine Mine Safety and Environment Association, Federated Distributors, Incorporated, Fly Ace Corporation, Liwayway Marketing Corporation, SM Retail, and the United Nations Development Programme. 

Diwata’s leaders based in Rizal, led by Annie Dee and Lita Lee, provided vehicles, manpower and a venue to pack the donated goods. 

These contributions benefitted more than 700 individuals, including Dumagat-Remontado families and schoolchildren of Magata-Manggahan Elementary School.  More than providing material support, the project partners expressed care and solidarity, reminding us that development is not only measured in infrastructure, investment, or policy, but also in the strength of human connections. 

For Diwata, the anniversary celebration was not simply about marking another year. It was about affirming what it stands for: empowering indigenous communities, fostering partnerships, and advancing inclusive, sustainable, and people-centered development. 

In an era that calls for deeper collaboration and more purposeful leadership, Diwata’s anniversary outreach is just one example of how compassion, partnership, and shared responsibility can create lasting impact. 

 

 

Photo 1: 

 

Photo 2: Diwata’s trustees with South African Ambassador to the Philippines Bartinah Ntombizodwa Radebe-Netshitenzhe, Rizal Governor Nina Ynares and other project partners. 

May 18, 2026

The Middle East conflict involving the United States, Israel, and Iran remains active but has entered a period of unstable ceasefires and intermittent confrontation. Since its escalation in early 2026, the conflict has been marked by intermittent maritime incidents, shipping disruptions, and persistent geopolitical tension. While diplomatic negotiations continue, the situation has stabilized into a prolonged standoff characterized by recurring risk rather than decisive military confrontation. 

The most consequential effects of the conflict have been economic rather than military. Energy markets have absorbed a sustained geopolitical risk premium, resulting in elevated oil prices, increased shipping costs, and heightened volatility across global supply chains. These changes affect not only energy-importing countries but also industries dependent on international trade and transportation. 

For import-dependent economies such as the Philippines, the conflict has introduced a structural shift in economic risk. Even if hostilities diminish, uncertainty surrounding energy supply routes and shipping infrastructure is likely to persist. Governments and industries must therefore adapt to an operating environment defined by sustained volatility rather than temporary disruption. 

Mining remains one of the most strategically significant sectors of the Philippine economy, serving as a major source of export revenue, regional employment, and industrial raw materials for global manufacturing and energy systems. The country is among the world’s leading producers of nickel and an important supplier of copper and gold, positioning it as a critical participant in international mineral supply chains. Because mining operations depend heavily on energy, transportation, and global commodity markets, the sector is highly sensitive to geopolitical developments that affect fuel prices, shipping routes, and industrial demand. 

Implications for the Philippine Mining Industry 

The Philippine mining industry faces a complex set of consequences from the Middle East conflict. While geopolitical instability supports higher commodity prices, rising operating costs reduce profitability. 

Periods of geopolitical instability often support higher prices for safe-haven and industrial metals particularly gold, while supply disruptions and industrial demand can influence prices for minerals such as nickel and copper. This improves export revenue potential for mining companies. However, higher fuel, electricity, and transportation costs increase the cost of extracting and delivering minerals. 

The resulting economic environment is characterized by constrained profitability, where revenue gains are offset by cost inflation. Long-term competitiveness will depend on operational efficiency, cost control, and supply chain resilience. 

Nickel mining is one of the most strategically significant sectors in the Philippine mining industry. Disruptions in global supply chains—particularly those affecting inputs used in mineral processing—have increased production costs in competing jurisdictions. This dynamic has supported higher global nickel prices and strengthened demand for Philippine exports. However, the benefits remain conditional because mining operations remain highly sensitive to energy costs. Rising fuel and power prices can offset gains from higher commodity prices. 

Copper and gold producers occupy a relatively resilient position in the mining sector. Gold serves as a financial safe-haven asset during periods of geopolitical uncertainty, while copper demand remains linked to infrastructure development and industrial growth. These commodities are therefore likely to maintain stable demand despite market volatility. However, rising operating costs continue to place pressure on profit margins. 

Coal producers may benefit indirectly from higher global energy prices as utilities seek alternative fuel sources. However, increased diesel and equipment costs offset part of this revenue advantage. The net effect on the coal mining sector is moderate rather than transformative, with incremental revenue gains balanced by rising operating expenses. 

Industrial and Logistics Implications for the Mining Supply Chain 

Energy-intensive industries such as cement manufacturing are among the most negatively affected sectors. Rising fuel and electricity costs increase production expenses, while competitive market conditions limit the ability of companies to pass these costs on to consumers. This imbalance results in margin compression and increased financial risk. Over time, firms may invest in energy efficiency and alternative fuels, but these adjustments require capital investment and implementation time. 

Shipping and logistics infrastructure plays a critical role in the competitiveness of the mining industry. Geopolitical instability increases insurance costs, fuel expenses, and transit times for cargo vessels. These changes raise the cost of transporting minerals and reduce delivery reliability. The primary risk facing the logistics sector is cost escalation rather than physical supply disruption. Transportation efficiency has therefore become a key determinant of mining profitability and export performance. 

Structural Exposure to Imported Energy 

The Philippine energy system relies heavily on imported fuels, including crude oil and coal. The Philippines is becoming increasingly increasingly reliant on liquified natural gas (LNG) as domestic natural gas supply declines. The country is currently in a transition phase from domestic natural gas to imported LNG, which means reliance is rising and will likely become significant within the next decade. 

This dependence creates a systemic vulnerability to geopolitical instability in major energy-producing regions. Because domestic energy resources remain limited relative to national demand, changes in global fuel markets rapidly affect electricity prices, industrial production costs, and household expenditures. 

The immediate consequence of the Middle East conflict has been rising costs rather than supply shortages. Energy deliveries continue, but transportation risks and insurance premiums have increased significantly. These additional costs propagate through the energy supply chain—from fuel importation to power generation and distribution—ultimately reaching consumers in the form of higher electricity and fuel prices. 

The Philippine energy sector is therefore transitioning from a relatively stable cost environment to one characterized by sustained volatility. Energy planning and investment decisions must now incorporate uncertainty related to fuel prices, shipping costs, and exchange rates. 

Five operational effects define the current risk landscape for the Philippine energy sector. First, rising global oil and gas prices have increased operating costs for power plants, transportation systems, and industrial facilities. These increases contribute to inflationary pressure across the economy. 

Second, generation costs have risen significantly, particularly for facilities dependent on imported fuels. Price volatility complicates operational planning and increases financial risk for electricity producers. 

Third, the conflict has intensified pressure on national energy security policy. Government agencies have prioritized fuel supply stability, infrastructure resilience, and strategic reserve management. 

Fourth, renewable energy has become more economically attractive as fossil fuel costs rise. This shift will accelerate investment in renewable generation, storage systems, and grid modernization. 

Fifth, currency fluctuations have amplified the cost of energy procurement because most fuel imports are denominated in foreign currency. 

Together, these developments signal a fundamental transition in the Philippine energy sector—from a system focused primarily on supply adequacy to one increasingly centered on risk management and resilience. 

Sectoral Impacts Across the Philippine Energy System 

The oil importation sector remains the most immediately exposed to geopolitical instability. Because the Philippines relies heavily on imported petroleum products, disruptions in international shipping particularly in the Strait of Hormuz directly increase procurement costs and financial risk. Even when supply volumes remain stable, higher transportation and insurance costs increase the total cost of fuel imports. 

The power generation sector is structurally vulnerable to fuel price volatility because the Philippine electricity system depends heavily on imported energy sources. Rising fuel costs increase electricity production expenses and create pressure for higher consumer tariffs. 

Utilities operating under regulated pricing frameworks in the Philippines generally remain financially stable because fuel and power procurement costs are allowed to be passed through to consumers. However, increases in electricity prices often trigger regulatory review and public scrutiny, creating reputational and policy risks for utilities. Independent power producers face greater financial exposure, particularly when operating under fixed-price contracts or merchant market conditions where revenues may not fully offset rising fuel and operating costs. Key sector risks therefore include sustained increases in generation costs, tariff pressure, intensified regulatory oversight, and operational uncertainty. 

The LNG sector represents both vulnerability and opportunity. In the short term, rising global gas prices increase generation costs and supply risk. In the long term, LNG infrastructure development is expected to expand as policymakers seek to diversify energy sources and improve supply reliability. LNG therefore plays a transitional role in strengthening energy security while supporting the shift toward a more diversified energy mix. 

Renewable energy is the primary structural beneficiary of sustained geopolitical instability. Unlike fossil fuel-based generation, renewable energy relies on domestic resources and is less vulnerable to international supply disruptions. As fossil fuel prices become more volatile, renewable energy projects become increasingly competitive in operating cost and energy security terms. Governments and investors should prioritize renewable energy as a strategic component of energy security and economic stability. Over time, renewable energy is expected to transition from a supplementary energy source into a core pillar of the Philippine energy system. 

Probable Future of the Conflict and Strategic Outlook 

The most probable future trajectory of the Middle East conflict is a prolonged period of geopolitical tension rather than a decisive military resolution. While large-scale escalation remains unlikely, underlying strategic rivalries are expected to sustain recurring instability. 

This environment creates three enduring conditions: persistent energy price volatility; increased maritime transportation risk; and sustained supply chain uncertainty. These conditions represent a structural transformation in the global risk landscape. 

The prolonged nature of geopolitical instability will reinforce the vulnerability of the Philippine energy system while accelerating structural changes in energy policy and investment. Three major trends are expected to define the sector’s evolution: sustained cost volatility; increased pressure for energy diversification; and accelerated renewable energy  investment. Energy planning will increasingly focus on resilience, flexibility, and risk management rather than solely on supply expansion. 

On the other hand, the Philippine mining industry is expected to benefit from sustained global demand for critical minerals while facing rising operational costs. Three structural trends are likely to shape the sector: stable demand for strategic minerals; increasing production and logistics costs; and growing strategic importance in global supply chains. In periods of global instability, mining can simultaneously benefit from rising mineral prices while facing increased operating costs, creating a complex economic environment in which opportunity and risk coexist. 

Conclusion 

The Middle East conflict will not derail the development of the Philippine mining and energy industries but it will permanently reshape the rules under which they operate. Energy will become costlier and more strategically sensitive to global events, while mining will become increasingly critical to international supply chains even as sustaining production grows more expensive. 

The deeper implication is structural. Geopolitical risk is no longer episodic; it has become embedded in the global economic system. For the Philippines, this means planning for volatility rather than stability. Investment decisions, infrastructure development, and resource policy will need to be designed around resilience, diversification, and long-term risk management. In this new environment, uncertainty is not a temporary challenge; it is the baseline condition. 



Fernando “Ronnie” S. Penarroyo specializes in Energy and Resources Law, Project Finance and Business Development. He is also currently the Chair of the Professional Regulatory Board of Geology, the government agency mandated under law to regulate and develop the geology profession. For any matters or inquiries in relation to the Philippine resources industry and suggested topics for commentaries, he may be contacted at fspenarroyo@penpalaw.com. Atty. Penarroyo’s commentaries are also archived at his professional blogsite at www.penarroyo.com 

May 18, 2026

For years, discussions surrounding mining in the Philippines have largely focused on permitting, environmental concerns, social acceptability, and the perennial question of whether we are deriving sufficient value from our mineral resources.  

Today, however, the conversation has evolved to highlight the role of critical minerals in the development of the Philippine mining industry. Critical minerals are progressively regarded as strategic assets: essential not only to economic development, but also to energy transition, technological innovation, and even national security. 

Nickel, copper, cobalt, and rare earth elements have become central to the global transition toward electric vehicles, renewable energy, battery storage, and advanced technologies. 

For the Philippines, this shift presents both an opportunity and a challenge. 

Recent months have seen a number of developments positioning the Philippines more prominently within global critical minerals supply chains. 

Most significant was the signing in February 2026 of a Memorandum of Understanding between the Philippines and the United States on cooperation in critical minerals supply chains. The agreement seeks to strengthen cooperation on responsible mining, mineral processing, investment, and supply chain resilience. This reflects a growing recognition among major economies that secure and diversified mineral supply chains are now matters of strategic importance. 

This aligns with the initiatives of other mining jurisdictions such as Australia and Canada to work with the Philippines in prioritizing critical minerals as strategic and national security assets rather than merely commodities.  These efforts have also been referred to as “mining diplomacy”. 

Meanwhile, global demand for nickel and copper continues to rise as countries accelerate renewable energy initiatives. For mineral-rich countries such as the Philippines, this creates pressure to reconsider the longstanding export-oriented model. 

The real value of critical minerals lies not merely in exporting ore, but in participating in higher-value activities such as refining, precursor manufacturing, battery materials processing, and associated industrial ecosystems. Whether the Philippines can successfully move into these areas remains one of the defining policy questions facing our mining industry. 

Increasingly, this conversation on critical minerals also intersects with innovation and intellectual property. 

The race to secure critical minerals is not limited to access to mineral deposits. It also involves competition over the technologies used to process minerals more efficiently, reduce environmental impacts, improve battery performance, and develop alternative extraction and recycling methods. In many respects, the future value of critical minerals may depend as much on technology and know-how as on geology itself. 

Countries that succeed in downstreaming are often those that build ecosystems supporting research, technical capability, and technology transfer alongside extraction activities. Patents, proprietary processing technologies, licensing arrangements, and collaborative research partnerships are becoming increasingly important components of the global critical minerals landscape. 

Innovations come not just from the mining companies themselves, but other companies in the ecosystem, including those that specialize in mining equipment, technology and services (METS) which use IP to pursue their internationalization strategies.  

As examples, Australia and Canada are using innovation and intellectual property strategies to move beyond traditional extractive mining models and capture greater value from the critical minerals supply chain. In both jurisdictions, mining companies are investing heavily in proprietary mineral processing technologies, environmentally sustainable extraction methods, recycling systems, and advanced metallurgical processes. Companies are also actively securing patents and exclusive licensing arrangements covering new recovery technologies for critical minerals and rare earth elements, recognizing that future competitiveness will depend not only on access to mineral deposits, but also on control of the technologies used to process and refine them. 

A notable element in both countries is the strong collaboration among mining companies, universities, government research institutions, and technology developers. In Australia, mining innovation is increasingly driven by partnerships with institutions such as the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organization or CSIRO [the equivalent of our Department of Science & Technology (DOST)] and leading universities, with technologies later commercialized through licensing and joint venture arrangements. Locally, DOST’s Philippine Council for Industry, Energy and Emerging Technology Research and Development (DOST-PCIEERD) focuses on strengthening the local mining and minerals sector through research, development, and value-addition initiatives, including transforming raw mineral resources into higher-value, sustainable products. 

Canada, meanwhile, has placed particular emphasis on IP commercialization and integrating mining into broader EV, battery, and clean technology supply chains. Canadian initiatives likewise focus on helping mining companies identify, protect, and monetize valuable IP assets arising from mining innovation. 

For the Philippines, critical minerals, IP and innovation present an important but often overlooked opportunity. 

The country’s participation in the critical minerals economy should not be viewed solely through the lens of extraction and processing. There is also space to develop local expertise in mining technologies, environmental solutions, mineral processing innovations, and sustainability practices adapted to Philippine conditions. 

Several examples already demonstrate that innovation within Philippine mining is possible. 

Some Philippine mining companies have adopted real-time environmental monitoring systems that allow continuous monitoring of water quality, rainfall, slope movement, and tailings facilities. These technologies improve risk management while also strengthening transparency and regulatory compliance. 

Other companies have invested in progressive mine rehabilitation techniques, including the use of native species propagation, biodiversity mapping, and drone-assisted monitoring of rehabilitation areas. In a country highly vulnerable to climate and biodiversity risks, innovations in rehabilitation and watershed management may become increasingly valuable forms of mining expertise. 

Digitalization is also beginning to reshape Philippine mining operations. The use of geographic information systems, drone surveying, automated fleet management, and remote sensing technologies has improved operational efficiency and safety in several large-scale mining projects.  

As artificial intelligence and predictive analytics continue to evolve, opportunities abound for Philippine mining companies and local technology providers to develop solutions tailored to the country’s unique geological and environmental conditions. 

Beyond operational technologies, the Philippines may also have opportunities in mineral processing innovation itself.  For example, research into more energy-efficient nickel processing methods, low-carbon mineral refining, mine waste recovery, and circular economy technologies could become increasingly relevant as global industries seek more sustainable supply chains. The country’s extensive experience with lateritic nickel ores may also create opportunities for specialized technical expertise in processing ore types commonly found in tropical environments.  In time, Philippine-developed technologies or environmental management practices may themselves become exportable expertise. 

Strengthening intellectual property awareness within the mining sector will therefore become increasingly important. Mining companies often focus primarily on permits, operations, and production targets, yet proprietary technologies, software systems, environmental processes, and technical solutions may also represent valuable intellectual assets. 

As the Philippines mining industry evolves, our competitive advantage will increasingly depend not only on who possesses critical minerals, but on who develops the knowledge, systems, and technologies surrounding them. 

May 18, 2026

The Writ of Kalikasan is a bell in the storm. But not every noise is a fire, and not every fire is visible from the courthouse steps.

That is the difficult wisdom running through two recent Supreme Court decisions: Batan v. MGB and Altai Philippines Mining Corporation, decided on Nov. 4, 2025; and Protect Manicani Island Society (PROMISI) v. DENR and Hinatuan Mining Corporation, decided on Jan. 28, 2026. One case feared the scarring of forests and seas; the other, the slow drowning of protected island ecology in silt, pollution, and unrehabilitated mines. Both involved island communities. Both invoked the country’s most dramatic environmental remedy. Both petitions failed.

It would be easy to misread the cases as a judicial cold shoulder to environmental protection. They are better understood as an attempt to tune the instrument: to make the bell sensitive enough to detect real danger, but precise enough not to ring at every shadow.

The writ was born from the Supreme Court’s 2010 Rules of Procedure for Environmental Cases. It gave procedural muscle to the constitutional right to a balanced and healthful ecology. It may be invoked when an unlawful act or omission causes or threatens environmental damage of such magnitude as to prejudice life, health, or property in two or more cities or provinces. The petition must be supported by relevant and material evidence, including scientific or expert studies.

That design was both bold and cautious. Bold because it allowed citizens, communities, and public-interest groups to bring large-scale ecological harm directly to the higher courts. Cautious because it did not make every environmental dispute a constitutional emergency.

The need for such a remedy is hardly academic. The Philippines ranked first among 193 states in the 2024 World Risk Index, with a score of 46.9. The World Bank has warned that, without action, climate change could reduce Philippine GDP by as much as 13.6 percent by 2040, with the poorest households hit hardest. These figures are not decorative footnotes. They are the country’s weather forecast in legal form.

But environmental law has always had a timing problem. It is asked to act before harm becomes ruin while still demanding proof before harm becomes obvious. It must hear the crack in the dam before the flood, but not mistake every creak for collapse.

In Batan, the difficulty was geography. The petition involving Sibuyan Island in San Fernando, Romblon, failed to satisfy the rule’s requirement that the harm affect inhabitants in “two or more cities or provinces.” In PROMISI, the Court found the petition lacking in proof. Allegations of ecological harm on Manicani Island in Guiuan, Eastern Samar, could not substitute for substantial evidence showing damage of the required magnitude. Together, the cases expose the writ’s double lock: scale and science.

Both locks serve a purpose. Without scale, courts could be asked to resolve every localized environmental dispute as if it were a national catastrophe. Without science, the writ could become an all-purpose injunction, allowing anxiety to disguise itself as evidence.

Yet locks can also keep out the very people they were built to protect.

The two-city-or-province threshold is sensible on a flat map. The Philippines, however, is not a flat map. It is an archipelago of ecological singularities. A reef, watershed, island forest, or mountain ecosystem may be irreplaceable even if it lies within one province. A wound can be local and still be fatal. A small island can carry a large truth.

This is why Senior Associate Justice Marvic Leonen’s concurrence in both cases matters. He accepted the outcome under the present rules but proposed an “ecosystem approach”: courts should not measure environmental magnitude only by political boundaries, but also by the gravity of harm to a distinct ecosystem. That insight points the writ toward a more mature future — one that looks beyond the map without abandoning the microscope.

That middle ground is where the hard cases live.

The country cannot pretend that development is a dirty word. The clean-energy transition itself is mineral-hungry. The International Energy Agency projects that, under stated policies, lithium demand could grow fivefold by 2040, while graphite and nickel demand could double. Demand for cobalt and rare earth elements is also expected to rise strongly. The Philippines, meanwhile, is a leading producer of nickel and a significant producer of gold and copper, even if mining remains a relatively small share of GDP.

What Batan and PROMISI invite, then, is not a sermon to one side or a victory lap for another. They invite a common grammar.

Communities should not have to translate lived fear into impossible science before they are heard. But courts cannot decide based on fear alone. Regulators should be accorded technical respect. But expertise cannot be treated as a black box with a government seal.

Permitted enterprises need not be crippled by suspicion or slogans. But they must still bear the weight of scrutiny.

The better path is not more litigation or less litigation. It is better environmental truth.

That means petitions supported by baseline data, hydrology, biodiversity inventories, geohazard analysis, reef surveys, water-quality results, and causal pathways. It also means public access to environmental information that often exists but remains buried in agency files: impact assessments, Environmental Compliance Certificate conditions, monitoring reports, compliance audits, and inspection findings. The courthouse should not be the first place where environmental facts see daylight.

The brilliance of the Writ of Kalikasan was that it understood environmental harm as different from ordinary injury. It can be dispersed, delayed, cumulative, and intergenerational. Its victims may not yet be born. Its proof may arrive like rainwater in a jar: drop by drop, until suddenly the measure is full.

The next stage is to make the writ more intelligent. Keep it extraordinary, because ordinary disputes should not summon constitutional thunder. But do not let extraordinariness become blindness to extraordinary ecosystems. Demand science, but do not make science a dialect spoken only by the powerful. Respect boundaries, but remember that rivers, reefs, sediment, wind, and risk do not stop at provincial borders.

That is the challenging work of calibration. If tuned too loosely, the writ becomes noise. If tuned too tightly, it becomes silence.

And silence, in environmental law, is rarely neutral. Sometimes it is only the sound a forest makes after the last tree has fallen, the sound of a reef after the fish have left, the sound of a promise still beautiful in doctrine but disappearing in the tide — writ, finally, in water.

March 30, 2026

In the nickel provinces along the Pacific coast, the day begins with a quiet defiance of tradition. Before sunrise, a woman heads to a mine site carved into the laterite hills. By first light, she is already in the field—examining rock faces and collecting samples, reading the earth like a story that may reveal whether the deposit holds promise.

At six in the morning, another woman, helmeted and gloved, leads a toolbox meeting before the first haul truck rolls out. As the sun climbs, a planning engineer traces the contours of the pit, imagining haul roads and benches taking shape in the early light. Farther down the haul road, a heavy equipment operator sets tens of tons of ore in motion.

Each of them is a woman.

Not long ago, that fact would have been remarked upon—perhaps even celebrated. Today, it passes without comment, at least on site. Beyond the perimeter of the mine, however, the numbers tell a different story.

For all its fluency in measurement, mining remains strikingly imprecise about one of its most consequential variables: who, exactly, is allowed to do the measuring.

The global gap that refuses to close

Across the global mining industry, women remain a statistical minority. A 2024 joint report by the World Bank and the International Finance Corporation estimates that women make up just 14–15% of the workforce in large-scale mining operations worldwide—a figure that has barely shifted in over a decade.

There are signs of progress, particularly among the largest corporations. The International Council on Mining and Metals reported in 2024 that its member companies—some of the world’s most influential mining firms—have increased female participation to around 20% of their workforce, alongside public commitments to reach gender parity by 2030. In some operations, women are increasingly visible in roles once considered off-limits, including equipment operators, pit supervisors, and metallurgists.

At the leadership level, the picture is cautiously improving. A 2024 McKinsey & Company analysis found that women now occupy roughly 18–20% of senior leadership roles in major mining firms, with board representation rising to about 25%, up from approximately 15% a decade ago.

However, progress has a geography. It is most visible in boardrooms and corporate headquarters, far removed from the dust and noise of extraction. At the operational core of mining—the pit floor, the underground shaft, and the machine yard—the industry remains overwhelmingly male.

A country shaped by extraction

In the Philippines, the imbalance is both familiar and uniquely consequential.

Mining contributes less than 0.5% of total national employment, accounting for roughly 200,000 direct jobs, according to government labor data. By urban economic standards, that is marginal. But mining does not operate on urban terms.

Its footprint is spatial, not statistical. A single mine can redraw the fiscal and physical map of a municipality—reshaping roads, water systems, and local economies, often within ancestral domains where questions of land, identity, and governance intersect. In such places, mining is not merely an industry. It is an architecture of influence.

And who participates in that architecture matters.

Within Philippine mining operations, women remain underrepresented. According to the Department of Environment and Natural Resources – Mines and Geosciences Bureau (2024), women account for roughly 10–15% of employees in large-scale mining, concentrated in geology, environmental management, laboratories, compliance, and community relations.

Figures from the Philippines Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (2023) suggest an even narrower participation rate of about 12% overall, with women comprising only 9–11% of the workforce in metallic mining operations.

The metaphor often used for gender barriers—the glass ceiling—feels misplaced here. In mining, the ceiling is sedimentary. It is layered over time, compacted by culture, and resistant to sudden change.

The quiet business case

For decades, gender inclusion in mining was framed as a question of fairness. Increasingly, it is understood as a question of performance.

A growing body of research suggests that gender diversity strengthens governance and operational outcomes in extractive industries. According to UN Women’s 2023 analysis, companies with greater female representation tend to exhibit stronger environmental and social governance performance, particularly in areas such as community engagement and compliance.

The financial case is equally compelling. A 2023 study by White & Case, examining large mining companies globally, found that firms with at least 40% female board representation recorded, on average, a 6% higher return on capital employed than their less diverse counterparts.

In a sector where investment horizons stretch across decades and capital expenditures run into billions, six percentage points is not a rounding error—it is a structural advantage.

Operational metrics tell a similar story. Research by the Responsible Mining Foundation, in collaboration with Harvard Kennedy School (2025), found that gender-diverse mining teams reported 12–15% higher safety compliance rates, along with lower injury incidents and improved employee retention.

In mining, where safety culture can determine not just productivity but survival, those differences are consequential.

The absence of women is not neutral. It carries a cost.

Beneath the numbers: culture and constraint

Part of the explanation lies in the pipeline. For decades, women represented only a small fraction of mining engineers in the Philippines—historical estimates place the figure at around 1.5% of registered professionals, reflecting longstanding barriers in technical education and industry entry.

But pipelines do not explain persistence. Culture does.

A 2022 survey by the Australasian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy found that 67% of women in mining reported experiencing sexual harassment, 70% reported bullying, and 85% identified gender inequality as a significant barrier to advancement.

Investigations in multiple jurisdictions have uncovered systemic misconduct in remote mining operations, particularly in fly-in, fly-out environments where isolation, hierarchy, and informality can converge into vulnerability. The details vary by site. The pattern does not.

In these environments, the cost of participation is not evenly distributed.

Hyper-masculine work cultures do not merely exclude—they recalibrate ambition, quietly and persistently, often invisibly.

What the women say

In Philippine mine sites, these dynamics are often expressed with restraint rather than protest.

“Some people still ask if I can handle the job,” one engineer said. “But when you’ve done it every day and done it well, performance answers for you.”

A heavy equipment operator offered a different perspective: “People think women are absent more,” she said. “But when you manage the household budget, you know what one day’s pay means. You show up.”

A senior executive pointed to a subtler calculus: “If a man is assertive, he’s seen as decisive. If a woman is assertive, she can be labeled difficult. That double standard—that’s one of the hardest layers to break.” These are not complaints. They are field notes.

Redrawing the silhouette of power

There are, however, signs of change—quiet, but unmistakable.

Geologist Nympha R. Pajarillaga now serves as chief operating officer of Apollo Global Capital, bringing decades of exploration and environmental expertise into executive leadership. Atty. Joan D. Adaci-Cattiling leads OceanaGold Philippines as president and general manager, shaping the direction of one of the country’s most visible mining operations. At Global Ferronickel Holdings Inc., Mary Belle D. Bituin serves as chief finance officer and head of human resources, influencing both fiscal discipline and organizational strategy.

These roles are not ornamental. They alter the lines of authority. Power in mining has always been visible in physical terms—who directs, who decides, who signs. Increasingly, it is being reconfigured in ways that are less immediately apparent but no less significant.

Law as scaffold, culture as structure

The legal framework for gender equality in the Philippines is already in place.

The Magna Carta of Women (Republic Act No. 9710) and the Women in Development and Nation-Building Act (Republic Act No. 7192) establish the state’s obligation to eliminate discrimination and promote equal participation across all sectors, including those historically dominated by men. But legislation alone rarely reshapes institutions.

As researchers such as Heimann and Johansson (2021) argue, meaningful change in mining requires structural redesign: transparent promotion systems, pay equity monitoring, flexible work arrangements, and workplace infrastructure that accommodates a diverse workforce. Inclusion cannot be decorative. It must be engineered.

Some companies have begun that work—retrofitting facilities, expanding cadetship programs, and embedding diversity metrics into governance systems. These are not trivial adjustments; they are foundational shifts. But they remain incomplete.

The coming expansion

Global demand for critical minerals—nickel, cobalt, and copper—is accelerating as economies transition toward renewable energy and electrification. The Philippines, already one of the world’s largest nickel producers, sits at a strategic inflection point.

The question is not whether mining will grow. It is whether that growth will replicate the past—or revise it.

Mining has always prided itself on uncovering what lies beneath the surface. Geologists read landscapes the way historians read archives. Engineers transform hidden deposits into tangible value. Investors speak, with practiced ease, of unlocking potential.

But the industry’s most underutilized reserve is not geological. It is human. It is present in the laboratory before sunrise, in the safety briefing before the shift begins, in the compliance office where permits are negotiated, in the boardroom where strategy is set, and in the cab of a truck waiting at the edge of the pit.

Women are not waiting to be included in mining’s future. They are already shaping it.

March 12, 2026

As the Philippines continues to pursue economic growth through the development of its natural resources, the relevance of laws, policies, and regulatory institutions has never been more critical.

The 2025 Geological Convention (GeoCon 2025), held in celebration of the Geological Society of the Philippines’ 80th Oak Jubilee, brought together geoscientists, policymakers, and industry practitioners to reflect on this challenge under the theme “Forged by Time, Strengthened by Integrity, Driven by Professionalism.”

The convention underscored a pressing national question: how well do existing legal and policy frameworks respond to evolving industry practices, societal expectations, and sustainability goals?

This article draws from the context of GeoCon 2025 and my plenary discourse on 02 December 2025 focusing on the continuing relevance of laws and policies in natural resource development, examining the need for stronger governance, updated regulatory frameworks, and deeper stakeholder collaboration to ensure responsible and equitable resource management in the Philippines.

Collectively, these policy instruments serve as the foundation for a resilient, low-carbon, and technologically adaptive economy aligned with international sustainability commitments.

Critical Minerals

The Philippines is positioned to play a major role in the global clean energy transition due to its large deposits of nickel, copper, cobalt, and other strategic minerals. These materials are essential for manufacturing electric vehicle batteries, wind turbines, solar technologies, and energy storage systems.

However, the country currently captures only a small portion of the value chain, as most minerals are exported in low-value form. To shift toward value-added processing, the government must establish stable fiscal terms, investor certainty, and a clear industrial strategy that supports mineral processing, refining, and associated manufacturing.

This strategy also depends on energy affordability and infrastructure readiness. Processing plants require continuous, cost-effective, and preferably low-carbon electricity, which aligns mineral development with national decarbonization goals. In parallel, mining operations must uphold strict environmental safeguards, including responsible tailings management, watershed protection, progressive rehabilitation, and transparent monitoring systems.

Market rules should strike a balance between allowing mineral exports and encouraging domestic processing. A milestones-based export policy can help—letting new mines export early to recover costs and generate cashflow, while gradually shifting toward local value-added processing as capabilities develop.

At the same time, requiring transparent and fair off-take agreements ensures that pricing and supply arrangements are clear, competitive, and aligned with national development goals.

Petroleum Exploration (Natural Gas)

Natural gas remains a critical element of the Philippines’ power generation mix, providing stability, flexibility, and reliability as the share of intermittent renewable energy increases.

However, the Malampaya field is entering maturity, and without new discoveries or efficient management, the country may face supply shortages and volatility in electricity prices. To avoid this, policies must encourage exploration in frontier basins, provide predictable contract terms, and reduce regulatory risks that slow project development.

At the same time, the Philippines is expanding LNG import capability to supplement domestic gas. To manage this dual-source system effectively, government must clearly define quality standards, interconnection rules, tariff structures, and coordination mechanisms among gas suppliers, pipelines, power plants, and storage facilities. This prevents operational bottlenecks and ensures that both domestic and imported gas can be dispatched efficiently and competitively.

Strengthening midstream access rules—particularly for pipeline connections and terminal capacity—will reduce commercialization risk for new gas discoveries. Combined with transparent market operations and coherent energy planning, these reforms preserve reliability while supporting the gradual transition toward a cleaner power generation mix.

Renewable Energy

The Philippines has high potential for solar, wind, hydropower, and geothermal, but slow permitting, unclear land access, and transmission bottlenecks continue to delay project development. A one-stop, time-bound permitting system can greatly reduce administrative burden while maintaining environmental and social safeguards. Clear land acquisition and zoning rules are critical, especially for large-scale solar and onshore/offshore wind developments.

Geothermal energy offers continuous, baseload renewable power, which is especially valuable in balancing variable solar and wind generation. However, exploration and drilling are expensive and risky. Government-backed risk mitigation measures—such as drilling insurance, cost-sharing funds, or exploration guarantees—would encourage increased private participation and accelerate geothermal expansion.

Renewable energy growth also presents opportunities to build domestic industries, including manufacturing components, assembly of battery systems, and clean-energy-powered mineral processing. Tying renewable deployment to local supply-chain development ensures that job creation and economic value remain in the Philippines, not solely in imported equipment or foreign-operated generation assets.

Nuclear Energy

As the Philippines seeks long-term grid stability and low-carbon baseload power, nuclear energy is being considered as part of the future energy mix. However, this requires careful and comprehensive regulatory preparation. The Philippine nuclear regulatory authority must finalize licensing standards for both large reactors and Small Modular Reactors (SMRs), define inspection and safety protocols, and adopt international best practices on operational transparency and personnel qualification.

Nuclear development also requires public trust and robust emergency planning. This includes transparent siting studies, seismic and coastal safety assessments, evacuation and medical response planning, and ongoing community engagement. Additionally, clear long-term strategies for spent fuel storage, eventual decommissioning, and financial liability are crucial to ensure intergenerational safety and accountability.

To make early nuclear projects economically viable, government may need to establish long-term power purchase frameworks, capacity market recognition, and risk-sharing mechanisms with the private sector. Simultaneously, the national grid must be reinforced to integrate nuclear facilities and ensure system reliability.

Hydrogen

Hydrogen has the potential to support industrial decarbonization, long-duration storage, and clean transport, but the market is still emerging and requires policy support. To move from feasibility studies to pilot projects, the government should implement targeted incentives such as tax credits, preferential financing, and demand-side programs in refineries, industrial facilities, and bus or truck fleets.

A national Hydrogen Code must define standards for safety, blending with natural gas, pipeline transport, storage, fueling stations, and worker training. Establishing a Guarantee of Origin (GO) certification ensures hydrogen can enter international supply chains, especially where buyers require proof of low carbon emissions.

Native hydrogen development requires a clear resource governance framework that defines legal ownership, tenure terms, exploration work obligations, data reporting, and environmental safeguards.

Building on the early awards in Zambales and Pangasinan, regulations should ensure transparent exploration results and responsible operational practices. At the same time, a structured pilot-to-commercial pathway is needed—establishing safety protocols, community engagement requirements, and decommissioning plans for pilot sites, with a streamlined process for scaling up to commercial production if technical and environmental performance thresholds are met.

Artificial Intelligence, Data Privacy & Digital Governance

Open and standardized geoscience data can significantly reduce exploration risk and accelerate the identification of new mineral and energy prospects. By adopting an open-file data-sharing system, the government can ensure that geological maps, drill results, and resource assessments become accessible after reasonable confidentiality periods.

However, this openness must be paired with clear privacy and sovereignty safeguards, ensuring that sensitive information is handled responsibly and used to support—not undermine—local and national interests.

A modern exploration data governance framework should require companies to submit exploration results in structured, digital formats that can be quickly integrated into national geoscience databases. This allows new information to immediately improve the understanding of an area’s resource potential, supporting transparent decision-making for future exploration licenses and contract awards.

Such a system helps attract credible investors, reduces duplication of effort, and promotes more efficient, evidence-based resource development.

Data governance for digitalized operations should ensure that information generated from sensors, monitoring systems, and predictive maintenance tools is handled in line with national privacy regulations and emerging AI oversight frameworks. This means energy and resource companies must adopt secure data-handling practices, maintain clear audit trails, safeguard operational and customer information, and ensure that automated systems support—not replace—responsible human decision-making.

Grid Connection and Transmission

Many planned renewable and clean energy projects cannot proceed because transmission lines are insufficient or delayed. To unlock investment, grid expansion must be planned ahead of energy development, not after. This includes new transmission corridors, substation upgrades, and inter-island connectivity.

The grid must also be modernized to handle more variable renewable power, energy storage systems, hydrogen-to-power facilities, and eventually nuclear plants. Updating grid codes, reserve market rules, and system flexibility arrangements will enable a stable, resilient, and future-ready power system.

Geoscience Profession Action Points

The geoscience profession plays a pivotal role in the Philippines’ modernized energy and resources framework by ensuring that exploration, extraction, and resource management are grounded in scientific integrity and sustainability.

Geoscientists lead in mapping, evaluating, and managing critical minerals such as nickel, copper, and rare earth elements under the Enhanced Fiscal Regime for Mining, while also advancing subsurface studies for renewable, geothermal, and hydrogen energy development. Their technical expertise supports environmentally responsible extraction and provides a foundation for data-driven investment and policy decisions.

Beyond exploration, geoscientists are increasingly involved in advisory and regulatory roles—helping shape standards for environmental protection, carbon accounting, and geological safety.

By combining technical capability with governance and ethical responsibility, the geoscience profession strengthens national energy transition efforts, ensuring resource development that is sustainable, transparent, and beneficial for communities and investors alike.

Conclusion

The Philippines’ evolving energy and resources landscape demonstrates a powerful convergence of policy modernization, technological innovation, and sustainability-driven governance.

With forward-looking reforms spanning critical minerals, renewable energy, nuclear development, hydrogen, and digital transformation, the nation is laying a solid foundation for long-term energy security and economic competitiveness.

These efforts are not merely reactive responses to global trends—they represent a proactive commitment to reimagining national development through cleaner, more resilient, and inclusive systems of energy and resource management.

Ultimately, success will hinge on effective implementation, consistent regulatory clarity, and the meaningful integration of science, policy, and industry expertise.

By fostering collaboration among geoscientists, engineers, policymakers, and investors, the Philippines can ensure that each reform translates into real progress—empowering communities, preserving ecosystems, and reinforcing the country’s position as a regional model for sustainable energy governance.

March 12, 2026

As we celebrate International Women’s Month this March, I am reflecting on how our organization, Diwata – Women in Resource Development, Inc. (“Diwata”) has presented itself as a platform for enabling women's leadership through mentoring and presenting examples of strong women leaders in the mining industry. 

On 18 November 2025, on the sidelines of the Philippine Mine Safety and Environment Association’s Annual National Mine Safety and Environment Conference in Baguio,  Diwata hosted "Network to the Next Level", an informal discussion featuring Tanya Cambetis, Business Optimization Manager of Didipio Mine and Engr. Rodalee Ofiaza, Diwata’s incumbent President.   

Both speakers had fascinating stories to tell about how they navigated and thrived in a male-dominated industry.   Among our special guests were Sweden’s Ambassador to the Philippines, H.E. Anna Ferry, and Eleonore Rupprecht, Counsellor and Trade Commissioner of the Embassy of Canada to the Philippines. 

For many women in mining, the greatest challenge is often not technical competence or work ethic. It is confidence: finding the courage to speak, to lead, and to believe that leadership is attainable even when the path is unclear.  In telling the story of her career journey, Cambetis offered valuable lessons for women navigating these realities across the mining sector, including here in the Philippines. 

Cambetis did not enter mining through a conventional route. Her early career was far removed from heavy industry, and she did not begin with an engineering degree or a clearly defined leadership trajectory. Instead, her entry point was operational, hands-on, and deeply human. What followed was a career shaped by persistence, self-doubt, mentorship, both its presence and its absence, and an unwavering commitment to inclusion. 

Her role as Manager for Business Improvement and Optimization at the Didipio Mine places her squarely within leadership, yet her perspective remains grounded in the experiences that nearly pushed her out of the industry. 

Leadership Without a Map 

One of the defining features of women’s careers in mining is the lack of a visible leadership pathway. While technical roles may be clearly structured, progression into leadership often depends on informal networks, sponsorship, and confidence: areas where women are frequently disadvantaged. 

Cambetis’ experience reflects this reality. Despite capability and ambition, there were moments when she questioned whether she belonged. These doubts did not stem from an inability to perform, but from the absence of guidance and representation. Like many women, she struggled with the sense that leadership was something to be “invited into,” rather than claimed. 

When Mentorship Misses the Mark 

Mentorship is widely promoted as a solution to gender disparity in mining, yet Cambetis’ early experience with a women’s organization revealed a critical gap. While the initiative was intended to support women, it failed to make space for difference: difference in role, background, age, and life stage. 

At the time, she internalized this exclusion as a personal failure. In hindsight, it became clear that the issue was not a lack of fit, but a lack of inclusion. Representation alone is insufficient. Mentorship must be intentional, empathetic, and accessible to women across the full spectrum of mining roles, from operators to engineers to administrators. 

This lesson later shaped Cambetis’ own leadership approach. When she assumed mentoring and leadership roles, her guiding principle was simple but powerful: no woman should ever feel that she does not belong in a space created to support women. 

The Hidden Impact of Everyday Interactions 

One of the most compelling lessons from Cambetis’ journey is the long-lasting impact of small moments. A passing comment, a dismissive tone, or an unspoken exclusion can shape someone’s confidence for years. Conversely, a brief word of encouragement can re-direct an entire career. 

In mining environments, often hierarchical and high-pressure, this awareness is particularly important. Leadership is not confined to formal authority. It is exercised daily through behavior, language, and attentiveness to others. 

For women already in senior or influential positions, Cambetis’ experience serves as a reminder: someone is always watching, learning what leadership looks like by observing how it is practiced. 

Balancing Leadership and Life 

Cambetis’ career progression was accompanied by profound personal sacrifice. Leaving children to work remotely and overseas remains one of the most emotionally challenging aspects of mining careers for women. These decisions are rarely visible in performance metrics, yet they shape leadership resilience in profound ways. 

In the Philippine mining context, where family and community ties are deeply rooted, these experiences resonate strongly. Cambetis’ story reflects the reality that leadership does not require choosing between ambition and care, but demands honesty, support, and flexibility. 

Completing a mining engineering degree later in life became a defining milestone for Cambetis, not simply as a professional achievement, but as a demonstration of perseverance. It reinforced an essential message for women in mining: growth is not limited by age or timing. 

Letting Go of the Myth of Readiness 

A recurring barrier for women entering leadership is the belief that they must be fully prepared before stepping forward. Cambetis’ career illustrates how damaging this belief can be. 

Leadership does not require having all the answers. It requires curiosity, accountability, and willingness to learn. The expectation of perfection disproportionately affects women, often causing them to hesitate while opportunities pass. 

The turning point in Cambetis’ leadership journey came when she stopped allowing doubt to dominate her decisions. Saying “yes” before feeling ready did not diminish her effectiveness but accelerated her growth. 

For women developing leadership skills, this also means learning to claim space. Speaking up in meetings, sharing ideas, and encouraging quieter voices are all acts of leadership, particularly in environments where women remain underrepresented. 

A Call to Action for Women Seeking Mentorship and Leadership 

Cambetis’ journey offers a clear message to women in mining: do not wait for permission to lead. Leadership is built through action, persistence, and support networks intentionally cultivated over time. 

“If I could give one piece of advice about how my career has gone, it would be: don’t let that voice be the one that tells you that you don’t belong. When that voice says you can’t, or won’t, or shouldn’t, stand up and say I can, I will, and I absolutely should. Surround yourself with people who support and believe in you. Build your network, seek mentors, and be a mentor. The mining industry needs more women, and each one of us can make a difference”, says Cambetis. 

The Philippine mining industry needs women who are willing to step forward, support one another, and redefine leadership through inclusion.  

As Tanya Cambetis exhorted the attendees of our forum, “Stand up, speak out, and never let that voice of doubt define your path.” 

March 12, 2026

Days ago, the U.S. Supreme Court did something deceptively old-fashioned: it reminded a president that tariffs are not a vibe, not a threat, not a negotiating posture — but a tax, and taxes belong to Congress.

In Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump (decided Feb. 20, 2026), the Court held 6–3 that the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) does not authorize the President to impose tariffs. The Chief Justice’s opinion opens with the Constitution’s blunt allocation of power: “The Congress shall have Power To lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises.” The government, the Court noted, conceded the President has no inherent peacetime authority to impose tariffs, so everything depended on whether IEEPA’s phrase authorizing the President to “regulate … importation” could bear the weight of a worldwide import tax. 

It could not. The Chief Justice described the administration’s theory as resting on “two words separated by 16 others” — “regulate” and “importation” — to claim “independent power to impose tariffs” of essentially unlimited reach. That is not interpretation so much as alchemy. And because tariffs are an instrument with “major” economic and political consequences, the Court insisted on what it called “clear congressional authorization” before the Executive may claim such a power. 

That doctrinal move matters for the world beyond the courthouse. A tariff is not merely a cost; it is a signal that reorders investment and logistics. When the United States can impose a near-universal duty by emergency proclamation, every export-dependent country is forced to price in presidential volatility. When the Court narrows that pathway, it does not end uncertainty — but it changes its shape. 

The first proof came immediately. After the decision, President Trump moved to a new legal hook: Section 122 of the Trade Act of 1974, which permits a temporary import surcharge (up to 15%) for a limited period without prior congressional approval. Reuters reports the administration is also pointing toward other trade tools (like Section 301 investigations) that can still generate significant duties, though with more procedure and predicates. In short: the ruling weakens the President’s ability to impose instant, global tariffs under IEEPA — but it does not abolish the tariff state. It forces the White House to use narrower statutes, take more steps, and accept more legal vulnerability. 

What about tariffs “imposed on other countries”? If those duties were justified solely under IEEPA, the Court’s holding means they lack statutory authority and cannot be sustained on that basis. But a critical caveat is that many U.S. tariffs can be re-anchored to other laws — and the dissent itself practically supplied the roadmap. 

Justice Brett Kavanaugh dissented, joined by Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito. His argument is a study in executive pragmatism: if IEEPA allows the President to impose quotas or embargoes — even to block imports altogether — why would it forbid the “lesser” tool of tariffs, which merely condition importation on payment? Kavanaugh also criticized the majority’s reliance (in part) on the “major questions” canon and warned that, in foreign-affairs cases, courts should not apply that doctrine as “a thumb on the scale against the President.” Yet even he acknowledged the practical reality that “numerous other federal statutes authorize the President to impose tariffs,” including Section 232 and Sections 122, 201, and 301 of the Trade Act of 1974. The dissent’s bottom line is revealing: today’s decision is wrong, but the tariff machine can keep running — it will just run on different tracks. 

Now place Manila in that picture.

The Philippines is not a spectator to American tariff drama; it is one of the countries that absorbs its tremors. The U.S. is a major trading partner, and Philippine exporters — especially in electronics and related supply chains — are exquisitely sensitive to across-the-board U.S. duties that act like a tax on access. For an economy where trade in goods and services is roughly two-thirds of GDP by World Bank measures, tariff uncertainty is macroeconomic uncertainty. A “temporary” U.S. surcharge can become permanent in business planning, because factories and contracts do not turn on judicial syllabi. 

Here is the comparative twist: the Philippine Constitution anticipated this problem more cleanly than the American statute fight did. Article VI, Section 28(2) expressly allows Congress to authorize the President, “within specified limits” and “subject to … limitations and restrictions,” to fix tariff rates and related imposts. Delegation is not smuggled in through an emergency law; it is written in the constitutional design. 

And the Customs Modernization and Tariff Act (R.A. 10863) operationalizes that design with guardrails. Its “Flexible Clause” (Section 1608) empowers the President — upon recommendation and subject to stated limits — to increase, reduce, or remove existing import duty rates, and even impose an additional duty (not exceeding 10% ad valorem) when necessary, among other measures. It also makes the delegation politically reversible: the power may be withdrawn or terminated by Congress through a joint resolution. That is what “agility with accountability” looks like in statutory form. 

So the Supreme Court’s lesson is not simply “Trump lost.” It is that tariff power, when exercised at scale, is governance at its most invasive: it reaches straight into prices, jobs, and the cost of living — “access to the pockets of the people,” as the Court quotes Madison. In the United States, the Court has now insisted that Congress must clearly hand over that key before the President may use it. In the Philippines, Congress already can hand it over — but only with limits, procedures, and the ever-present possibility of taking it back. 

The deeper point is democratic ownership. When tariffs become a president’s improvisational instrument — raised, lowered, announced, threatened, relabeled — trade partners learn to treat policy like weather. The Court’s decision tries, in its own lawyerly way, to make trade policy political again: debated, enacted, and answerable. 

In an era when a “national emergency” can be declared as easily as a press conference, that is not judicial fussiness. It is constitutional hygiene. 

Noel B. Lazaro is general counsel of Global Ferronickel Holdings, Inc., a two-time Asian Legal Business In-House Counsel of the Year finalist, and a Top Tier In-House Counsel awardee of the In-House Community. He is also a law professor and columnist.

January 28, 2026

By Noel B. Lazaro and Reeno E. Febrero

There are moments in geopolitics when the choreography matters less than the quiet exchanges behind it. In late October in Busan, on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit, Donald Trump and Xi Jinping staged one of those scenes: a handshake, a photo-op, and a declaration that the rare-earths dispute was “settled.” In reality, the settlement was transactional. Washington agreed to ease a tranche of tariffs and reopen the door to large U.S. soybean shipments to China, while Beijing pledged a one-year pause on its threatened export restrictions on rare-earth minerals and magnets to the United States. Markets exhaled. Analysts sifted through tone and subtext. But the real story—the underlying logic of power at play—remained unchanged. The agreement did not reorder the world; it merely clarified the minerals that now anchor it.

For a century, great-power politics pivoted on barrels of oil. Then, at the height of the digital boom, it seemed the future would be written in bytes. But the energy transition—and the militarization of supply chains—have rearranged the hierarchy. The building blocks of modern life are no longer fossil fuels or data streams but the atoms embedded in things: lithium in batteries, cobalt in electronics, neodymium in magnets, gallium in chips. The periodic table has become a map of twenty-first-century geopolitical anxiety.

The world according to minerals

Rare earth elements—17 metals with names that sound like they belong to speculative fiction—are geologically abundant but industrially elusive. They rarely occur in high concentrations, and separating them from ore requires complex, hazardous processing. This is why the world’s dependence on China is not an accident but the result of decades of strategic investment.

Today, China mines about 70 percent of global rare earths, refines over 90 percent, and manufactures nearly all high-performance magnets, the essential cores of electric vehicles, wind turbines, and precision-guided weapons. In 2024, it exported 58,000 tonnes of magnets—a volume not just of trade but of leverage.

Even when Beijing loosened export licenses earlier this year, it did so after demonstrating a simple lesson: it can constrict supply at will. Goldman Sachs estimates that diversifying refining capacity will require a decade of massive capital outlay, assuming geopolitical conditions remain stable—which they will not.

The Busan announcement, then, was a strategic feint. A temporary pause is not a policy shift; it is a warning shot. Scholars call this “deterrence by demonstration”: wield the weapon once, then sheath it. The world will remember who holds the handle.

The global scramble to escape gravity

In Washington, the truce buys time for the Pentagon’s magnet stockpile and for chipmakers to secure alternative sources. In Brussels, it reinforces the urgency behind the EU Critical Raw Materials Act, which limits reliance on any single supplier to 65 percent. Canada has launched a Critical Minerals Alliance. Japan quietly expanded its Strategic Metals Reserve. The G7 is building buffers, offtake contracts, and recycling mandates.

Yet progress is uneven. According to the International Energy Agency, global demand for critical minerals will triple by 2040; demand for rare earths used in EV motors could grow sevenfold. But outside China, refining capacity is thin, fragmented, and vulnerable to political risk. The United States may have copper, but it lacks separation plants. Australia excels at mining but not processing. Europe has technology but few deposits.

“Security of supply,” once a term of art, has become the central preoccupation of ministries and militaries.

A Philippine story hiding in plain sight

The Philippines is rarely mentioned in rare-earths analyses—yet it should be. The archipelago sits atop one of the world’s richest mineral belts, including nickel, cobalt, and copper, the backbone metals of the energy transition. Geological surveys have also identified rare earth occurrences in Palawan and Nueva Vizcaya, comparable in concentration to deposits in China and the United States.

In 2024, the country produced ₱94 billion in nickel despite global price softness. But the economic story is incomplete. The Philippines exports raw ore—low value, high volume. The higher-order value, the conversion of ore into materials and components, continues to accrue to other economies. Only two hydrometallurgical processing plants operate nationwide—Taganito and Coral Bay—with a third planned in Leyte.

The result is a familiar trap: a resource-rich nation earning the smallest share of value.

A sector meeting its inflection point

In September 2025, a Philippine Mining Club luncheon on “green mining technologies” set the tone. There, Department of Science and Technology (DOST) Undersecretary Sancho A. Mabborang underscored that under the Harmonized National R&D Agenda 2022–2028, DOST has earmarked about ₱300 million for a critical minerals R&D roadmap for 2026–2028, with the long-term goal of positioning the Philippines as a hub for critical minerals and green technology applications, especially for electric vehicles.

A month after, at the Mining Philippines 2025 conference in Taguig, the conversation widened from laboratories to innovation. Speaking at a plenary session, Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) Undersecretary Carlos Primo David explained that new regulations and the auctioning of idle mineral assets aim to lift mining’s share of GDP from about 0.5 percent to roughly 2 percent and revive long-stalled tenements.

By November 21, at the StratBase ADR Institute’s Pilipinas Conference in Makati, the agenda had become explicitly strategic. DENR Secretary Raphael Lotilla announced that the agency is finalizing an executive order to establish a national framework for developing a critical minerals industry, stressing that “the goal is not simply to mine more, but to mine better, process smarter, and govern with integrity” so that the Philippines becomes a reliable contributor to the clean-energy transition.

In substance, that framework rests on three pillars: responsible exploration and extraction aligned with modern ESG standards; downstream processing and circular value chains that reduce dependence on ore exports; and domestic manufacturing that links minerals to industries—batteries, electronics, renewable energy, and defense. Lotilla has also signaled that environmental safeguards will be modernized to keep pace with innovation, climate realities, and market demand, a quiet rebuke to past eras when rules were either weakened or ignored.

Laws are evolving, but the challenge is coherence

Legal reforms point in the right direction. The Philippine Mining Fiscal Regime secures a fairer return for the State, the Corporate Recovery and Tax Incentives for Enterprises to Maximize Opportunities for Reinvigorating the Economy (CREATE MORE) Act directs incentives toward value-added processing, and the amended Investors’ Lease Act lengthens leases for foreign investors to support more sustained investment.

But these instruments need to hold together. Policy remains siloed. Agencies pull in different directions. The DENR cannot build a critical-minerals industry without synchronized work from the Departments of Trade, Science and Technology, Energy, Foreign Affairs, and, increasingly, Defense.

The reality is stark: China’s advantage is not mineral abundance but metallurgical mastery. If the Philippines desires a place in the global value chain, it must build capacity not just to extract but to transform.

ASEAN’s moment—and a door for the Philippines

The geopolitics of minerals is shifting toward Southeast Asia. ASEAN produces nearly half the world’s nickel and over a third of its tin. Indonesia has used export bans to force domestic processing, with significant success. Vietnam is entering the magnet industry. Malaysia and Thailand house advanced electronics clusters. The region is becoming a manufacturing basin searching for secure inputs.

The Philippines could be the bridge: a mining powerhouse on the supply side, linked geographically and economically to manufacturing hubs.

The U.S.-led Minerals Security Partnership is looking for “second-source” jurisdictions—reliable alternatives to China. Regional manufacturers—from Japan to South Korea—seek diversified supply chains anchored in ESG compliance.

Recognizing the fluidity of global supply chains, the StratBase ADR Institute observes that Manila could strengthen its position by securing a long-term commitment from Washington, ensuring relevance within the U.S.-led critical-minerals network.

But they will only invest where institutions are predictable.

Material power in a fragile age

The deeper lesson of the Busan truce is that geopolitical rivalry is now embedded in the stuff of things. Nations that control the minerals and manufacturing of the energy transition will shape the century that follows.

But the world also faces a paradox: the clean-energy future requires extracting more minerals, not fewer. Each electric vehicle needs six times more mineral input than a combustion car; each offshore wind turbine needs nine times more rare earths than its fossil-fuel equivalents. The green transition is, in this sense, a mining story.

This raises a fundamental question for resource-rich democracies like the Philippines: will we remain exporters of the past or architects of the future?

To choose the latter will require industrial policy, environmental credibility, social legitimacy, and geopolitical clarity—an alignment of institutions rarely attempted, let alone sustained.

The rarest resource of all

When Trump and Xi posed for cameras in Busan, it was easy to imagine a world on pause. But the clock did not stop. Demand for critical minerals continues to rise. Refining bottlenecks grow sharper. The energy transition accelerates, even as geopolitical tension thickens.

Beneath our feet lie minerals that could define—not merely enrich—the country. They will not wait for us to decide.

In a century shaped by materials more strategic than oil and more enduring than currency, foresight is the rarest resource of all.


Noel B. Lazaro and Reeno E. Febrero serve with Global Ferronickel Holdings, Inc. They were recognized at the 2025 Asian Legal Business Philippine Law Awards as finalist for In-House Counsel of the Year and winner of Young In-House Counsel of the Year, respectively. They teach law and write opinion columns.

November 05, 2025

Minerals, Data, and a New Kind of Resource Wealth 

By Fernando Penarroyo 

The Philippines has long been recognized as one of the world’s most mineral-rich countries. With deposits of nickel, copper, and gold, it plays a vital role in global supply chains, especially at a time when electric cars, batteries, and renewable energy systems are driving demand for these resources.  

Even though mining can create jobs, bring in much-needed revenue, and connect the Philippines to international markets, there is still the lingering perception that it can harm the environment and displace communities. 

Now, another kind of resource is taking center stage alongside minerals—data. Mining in the twenty-first century is not only about extracting ores from the earth; it is also about gathering information.  

While mining companies use drones to map terrain, satellites to track environmental changes, and sensors to monitor everything from air quality to worker safety, they also collect information from host communities and indigenous peoples.  

Through surveys on health, demographics, and community sentiment, mining companies are no longer just extracting resources from the ground, they also “extracting” information from people and the environment. 

Handled poorly, this new form of extraction can create serious risks for privacy, fairness, and sovereignty. But handled well, it can be turned into an opportunity to strengthen communities, improve governance, and protect national interests.  

The Philippines has the chance to set an example by treating both minerals and data as shared resources that must be managed responsibly for the benefit of Filipinos. 

Digital Mining: How Data Transforms Operations 

Mining today is highly digitized. Advanced technologies have transformed operations, making it possible for companies to work more efficiently and safely. Drones are used to create detailed maps of landscapes, satellites help track changes in forests and water bodies, and sensors provide constant updates on machinery and safety conditions. These tools generate huge amounts of data that can be used to comply with environmental rules, improve productivity, and reduce accidents.  

Beyond technology, mining firms also collect information directly from communities. Environmental and social impact assessments often involve surveys about health and livelihoods, while corporate social responsibility programs may gather data on education and living standards. In some cases, companies or their contractors even monitor social media to see how people feel about mining projects. 

When collected and shared responsibly, this kind of information can be valuable. It can help companies respond more quickly to community concerns, give government agencies evidence to enforce rules, and provide communities with the data they need to push for better services.  

For example, if surveys show an increase in health issues near a mining site, this could become the basis for improved health care in the area. If water quality tests reveal pollution, communities could use this data to demand cleaner practices or compensation. In this way, data has the potential to balance power between corporations, the state, and its citizens. 

The Risks of Data Extraction 

However, risks arise when data collection is done without fairness or transparency. One of the biggest concerns is that communities may not give informed consent for how their data is used.  

Under the Indigenous Peoples’ Rights Act, indigenous groups must give their free, prior, and informed consent (FPIC) before mineral exploration and mining operations begin on their land.  

Yet FPIC usually does not extend to data collection. This means a community might allow a project to operate but not realize their personal information and opinions, or household details are being stored and possibly shared with third parties. 

Another issue is information imbalance. Often, companies collect data and share it with investors or government agencies but not with the very people from whom the information was generated and most affected by the operations.  

A mining company may test river water quality and submit a report to regulators saying conditions are safe, but families who depend on that water for farming or drinking may never see the full results. This creates an unfair situation where those who face the risks have the least access to the knowledge that could help them. 

There is also the potential for misuse. In areas where opposition to mining is strong, information about community leaders or activists could be used to monitor them. Even if this is not the intention, the risk remains that data collected for one purpose could later be applied in ways that put individuals at risk. 

Data as Resource Wealth 

Despite these challenges, data can be seen as an opportunity if it is treated as a resource in its own right. Just as minerals are considered part of national patrimony, there is a strong case for viewing mining-related data as a national asset.  

Companies see it as part of their business operations, but governments recognize its value for planning, monitoring, and security, while communities see it as essential for protecting their health and livelihoods. Balancing these interests is key. 

This debate mirrors the general struggle over mineral sovereignty. For decades, Filipinos have insisted that the benefits of mining flow to the nation before being repatriated abroad. The same logic can apply to information.  

The Philippines supplies large amounts of nickel and copper, which are critical for the global shift to clean energy. Investors often require access to operational data before they commit funds. If the Philippines asserts sovereignty over this information, it can make sure it is shared under terms that benefit the country, not just outside players. 

Mining Data, Geopolitics and National Security 

The strategic value of mining-related data goes beyond economics. Geological surveys, environmental records, and infrastructure maps have national security implications. If such information is stored abroad or left in foreign hands, the Philippines could lose control over knowledge about its own resources.  

This is especially important in a world where powerful nations like the United States and China are competing for control of supply chains for clean energy. In this context, protecting mining data is not only about fairness for host communities but also about protecting sovereignty at the national level. 

Handled wisely, mining data can enhance the Philippines’ negotiating position. A country that demonstrates strong data governance signals to investors and partners that it values not only economic efficiency but also sovereignty and rights. This can attract responsible investment, increase trust, and prevent exploitative practices. 

Toward Dual Stewardship of Resources and Data 

Critics of mining often use the term “extractivism” to describe the large-scale removal of resources that benefits outsiders more than locals. Increasingly, some fear that the same thing is happening with information. Data is being “extracted” from people without giving them anything in return.  

Yet the Philippines has an opportunity to change this narrative. Instead of allowing extractivism to dominate, the country can practice shared stewardship. This means treating minerals and data not as things to be taken but as resources to be managed responsibly, with benefits fairly distributed. 

Imagine if every community near a mine automatically received the results of environmental and health studies in plain, easy-to-understand language.  

Imagine if mining companies used the data they collect not just to meet legal requirements but also to invest in cleaner water, stronger health systems, and better local infrastructure. 

Imagine if the government stored mining data locally and used it to guide national plans for disaster preparedness and climate resilience.  

This is the vision of stewardship: turning data into a tool for empowerment. 

The Role of the Data Privacy Act of 2012 

The Data Privacy Act of 2012 (Republic Act No. 10173) provides a foundation for this. The law protects individual personal information in both government and private sectors by regulating the collection, processing, and storage of personal data.  

It created the National Privacy Commission to implement regulations, protect data subjects' rights, and ensure the country's data protection measures are in line with international standards.  

The law emphasizes transparency, legitimate purpose, and proportionality, meaning that data must be collected openly, only for clear reasons, and in amounts that are necessary. For mining companies, this means employee records, health surveys, and community data must all be handled responsibly. 

In practice, enforcement is still uneven. Many communities are not fully aware of their rights under the law, and the National Privacy Commission has limited resources to enforce such rights.  

Environmental regulators rarely coordinate with privacy regulators, leaving gaps in oversight. But these challenges can be addressed. With stronger cooperation, more training, and better resources, the Data Privacy Act can become a powerful tool for protecting and empowering both people and the nation. 

Artificial Intelligence and Data Privacy Issues 

Artificial intelligence (AI) is now integral to modern mining operations, optimizing exploration, production, logistics, and sustainability. However, this integration brings complex data-privacy challenges.  

AI systems in mining collect vast amounts of information ranging from worker biometrics to operational performance data, which may contain personally identifiable or sensitive industrial details.  

These systems often aggregate and analyze data across departments, leading to privacy risks such as surveillance concerns, unintentional re-identification, and exposure through third-party vendors or cross-border data transfers. 

The growing use of AI also introduces risks tied to the difficulty of explaining or contesting automated decisions affecting individuals.  

As AI systems become more involved in making or supporting decisions, it becomes harder for people and sometimes even for the companies using them to understand how or why those decisions were made. The Data Privacy Act demand stronger governance, emphasizing employee consent, data minimization, and transparency. 

Meanwhile, regulatory trends such as data localization are reshaping how global mining firms handle information.  

Data localization prohibits or restricts the transfer of certain types of data (especially personal, environmental, or strategic industrial data) to servers or cloud platforms located outside the country. The goal is to protect national sovereignty, privacy, and security by keeping sensitive data under Philippine jurisdiction. 

Beyond compliance, these measures have strategic implications. As AI turns data into a valuable asset, privacy management becomes central to maintaining corporate reputation and social license to operate. Breaches or unethical use of data could harm community trust and investor confidence.  

Ultimately, while AI enhances efficiency and sustainability, it also demands rigorous, transparent, and ethical data governance to ensure that innovation aligns with human rights and privacy standards. 

Policy Pathways: From Protection to Empowerment 

Several steps can help move toward this vision. Extending social license and community consent to cover digital data would give communities control over how their information is collected and used. Guaranteeing that communities have access to health and environmental data would ensure transparency.  

Requiring that sensitive mining information be stored properly would protect sovereignty. Including data practices in environmental impact assessments would mandate companies to explain not only how they treat land and water but also how they handle digital information. 

Strengthening the capacity of regulators and encouraging public-private partnerships could further build systems where digital data is shared responsibly. Each of these pathways transforms digital information from a potential liability into a tool for empowerment and development. 

Conclusion 

Mining in the Philippines has never been just about minerals. It has always been about who benefits, who bears the costs, and who gets to decide.  

In the digital age, this struggle now extends to data. Communities that once fought for land rights must now also claim their informational rights, while the state must balance local needs with global pressures. This is not only a challenge but also an opportunity.  

By protecting both natural and digital resources, the Philippines can move beyond extractivism and build a model of stewardship that is inclusive, sustainable, and sovereign. 

If mining is left unchecked, it could continue to drain both natural wealth and informational resources without fairly benefiting the country. But if managed wisely, the Philippines can turn mining into a force for justice and sustainability.  

Protecting both land and information ensures that communities are empowered, companies are accountable, and the nation secures its place in a competitive world. Mining responsibly and governing data fairly are not separate goals. They are part of the same fight for dignity, sovereignty, and the future of the Filipino people. 

Fernando “Ronnie” S. Penarroyo specializes in Energy and Resources Law, Project Finance and Business Development. He is also currently the Chair of the Professional Regulatory Board of Geology, the government agency mandated under law to regulate and develop the geology profession. For any matters or inquiries in relation to the Philippine resources industry and suggested topics for commentaries, contact him at fspenarroyo@penpalaw.com. Atty. Penarroyo’s commentaries are also archived at his professional blogsite www.penarroyo.com